Self-defeating racism in Utah's early labor movement

In the vast annals of Utah racism, it's hard to read the vicious anti-Chinese hate in the decades after the Golden Spike — a cause aggressively advanced by the early labor movement.

• This is Old News, where we backtrack into the past. As Labor Day approaches, we're looking at how workers here fought and what they were up against.

• In 1885, the Knights of Labor were up against their own bigotry.

Driving the news: The Knights, who were the first national labor federation, organized a boycott in Ogden against anyone they thought was too nice to Chinese people.

• They targeted a number of people who were previously sympathetic to the Knights, burning the tenuous goodwill they had established.

Context: Anti-Chinese hostility was becoming violent in Utah by 1885, with attacks by disgruntled white workers who believed Chinese immigrants were depressing wages, and at least one known lynching.

• In central Utah, white coal miners trapped a group of Chinese workers in a boxcar and sent it careening down a canyon.

Zoom out: Campaigns to "expel" Chinese workers were escalating throughout the West, including the killings of at least 28 Chinese miners in Rock Springs, Wyoming, in September 1885.

Details: Although the Knights of Labor disavowed the massacre, less than two weeks later they revived their calls to expel Chinese workers — and ramped up anti-Chinese rhetoric in Ogden, where fewer than 100 Chinese people lived.

The intrigue: The Knights of Labor, while amassing about 800,000 members nationally, had more precarious ties in Utah.

• Mormon leaders saw the group as secretive, and potential rivals, writes historian J. Kenneth Davies.
• Meanwhile, the ties to violence supplied plenty of legitimate objections in both the religious and secular press.

What happened: When the Knights printed their list of "Chinese-friendly" Ogdenites to boycott, the railroad town had enough.

• The Knights had to make retractions and try to repair ties on all religious sides.

• The Ogden Herald finally deemed the group's efforts there a failure.

The big picture: It was not the first or last time that organized labor allowed racism to flummox its goals.

• Employers, well aware of the animus at play, explicitly threatened to bring in Chinese workers as strikebreakers, all but guaranteeing division would continue.

Yes, but: In their zeal, the Knights pushed at least one of their boycott targets toward a more forward-thinking conclusion.

• Chinese and white workers should be paid the same, Ogden realtor Joseph West wrote, "destroying the bitter competition now existing between these races."

Previously in Old News:

• ⛏️ Xenophobic union-busting in the 1922 coal strike
• 🗞️ How Utah media spun an anti-union brawl in 1913
• 🛶 John Wesley Powell's crappy night
• 😈 How Lucifer took over a Utah newspaper during the satanic panic
• 📸 A photo history of Utah's impressive and bizarre Pioneer Day floats
• ⛷️ The great Alta freak-out of 1873
• 🍸 A big step toward booze
• 🎉 Ogden: More fun than Salt Lake City for at least 143 years