Philly's police watchdog faces uphill battle to investigate officers
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Illustration: Lindsey Bailey/Axios
Philadelphia's police watchdog celebrated its fifth anniversary this year. Unfortunately, there's not much to celebrate: The agency still can't investigate police misconduct.
Why it matters: Philadelphians' vision for police oversight has been thwarted so far by arbitrators who could again decide whether the Citizens Police Oversight Commission can fulfill its mandate.
The big picture: As the Parker administration and police union head back to the negotiating table, it's déjà blue for social justice advocates pushing for true independent police oversight.
- The current contract — a major win for police officers and a huge loss for CPOC — runs through June 2027, but both sides will exchange their initial proposals at the end of December.
- The Fraternal Order of Police has resisted allowing CPOC to investigate police officers, preferring to maintain the status quo with the department's Internal Affairs unit exclusively handling those probes.
Driving the news: The Parker administration plans to once again include independent oversight among its list of asks in the upcoming round of contract talks with the police union, Cara Leheny, acting director of the city's Office of Employee and Labor Relations, told city lawmakers during a hearing last week.
- But she also acknowledged the elephant in the room: Without a concession from the police union, the administration is "significantly limited" in what it can do to press for independent police oversight.
Catch up quick: Philadelphians voted in 2020 to give CPOC a legal mandate to investigate officers.
- But it was later revealed that the police union held veto power over that right and that it had to be bargained for in contract talks.
Between the lines: Arbitrators ultimately control what ends up in the police contract when negotiations reach an impasse — and last time they punted on giving CPOC the power to investigate police.
How it works: Under state law, police and firefighters don't have the right to strike — a tactic other city workers can use to press their cases for better compensation packages.
- To level the playing field, an arbitration panel steps in when contract negotiations reach an impasse, weighing each side's demands and deciding how best to juggle their competing interests.
Yes, but: In the past, the deck has been stacked in the police union's favor.
- The last contract was decided by a three-person panel that included two union-friendly arbitrators.
Reality check: CPOC is still forcefully pressing its case for independent oversight ahead of contract talks.
Zoom in: The agency's argument centers on the costs of what executive director Tonya McClary called a "broken system" while testifying before City Council last week — one that's not improving after the state Supreme Court dealt another blow to cities trying to get rid of rogue police officers.
- And another case involving a woman who was killed in a hit-and-run after police officers left her lying in the street.
- The woman's family has never learned whether the officers were disciplined, McClary said.
They're not alone: CPOC receives about 40 complaints a month from residents who "don't trust the police to police themselves," McClary said.
Case in point: Few police officers are ever disciplined over those complaints when they're investigated, per a 2021 report.
- And a previous CPOC audit found the department failed to address more than 130 misconduct allegations.
The bottom line: Unless something changes, McClary said, residents will be frustrated to learn their misconduct complaints are rerouted back to Internal Affairs, which is already carrying a massive backlog of cases.
- "Sometimes [residents] tell us, 'Never mind. I don't believe in that process,'" McClary said.
