Philadelphia pays $770K to 3 reinstated police officers
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Photo illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios; Photo: Paul Marotta/Getty Images
Philadelphia has shelled out more than $770,000 in back pay to three fired police officers who were reinstated through arbitration earlier this year.
Why it matters: The payments add to millions of dollars that taxpayers have footed in recent years to settle police misconduct claims.
Zoom in: Sgt. Joseph Przepiorka was among hundreds of officers accused by the Plain View Project in 2019 of making racist and offensive Facebook posts.
- A federal judge this week tossed out a lawsuit that Przepiorka and several officers filed against the city, ruling Philly officials were within their rights to terminate or discipline those officers.
By the numbers: Philadelphia paid Przepiorka more than $569,000 in back pay, city spokesperson Ava Schwemler tells Axios.
- Chief inspector Carl Holmes was paid $97,000, while officer Eddie Garro-Garcia got nearly $111,000.
Holmes won his job back in January after a sexual assault case against him collapsed.
- The arbitration decision upset one of the three subordinate female officers he was accused of assaulting, per the Inquirer.
Garro-Garcia had his firing reduced to a 45-day suspension. He was accused of making lewd comments to a woman while on duty in 2021.
- The woman died before she could testify at the arbitration hearing.
The big picture: The binding arbitration system makes it difficult for departments across the Commonwealth to challenge police disciplinary decisions favoring officers fired for misconduct.
- Between 2011 and 2019, the police union successfully fought to reduce or overturn discipline about 70% of the time, per a 2019 Inquirer analysis.
- But the Pennsylvania Supreme Court could change that in a pending case out of Philly involving a fired lieutenant who was reinstated after being accused of sexually harassing two female officers.
What we're watching: The city's total tab could soar close to $1 million, as its payment to officer Anthony McFadden is still pending.
- McFadden had his firing reduced to a suspension for using a racial slur during a conversation with a police dispatcher on a recorded line.
