Chicago alders demand probe around CFO departure
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Finance Committee chair Ald. Pat Dowell leads a press conference after the City Council approved a probe into the recent resignation of the city's chief financial officer. Photo: Monica Eng/Axios
The Chicago City Council voted Wednesday to review the circumstances around last week's abrupt departure of city chief financial officer Ashlee Gabrysch. She said staying in the role would compromise her integrity.
Why it matters: The overwhelming 45 votes supporting the independent review deliver a serious rebuke to Mayor Brandon Johnson in the middle of a contentious budget and election season.
- The city's continued financial disputes threaten its credit rating, which S&P put on notice Wednesday.
Catch up quick: When Gabrysch took the job in August, she became Johnson's third CFO in a year and was seen as a steadying force at a rocky time.
- Cracks emerged last month when Gabrysch publicly contested the administration's characterizations of how much of the city's deficit was being closed with reliable "structural" revenue.
- The administration said 76%, but she calculated 56%, noting that hundreds of millions in loans for police settlements shouldn't count as structural.
- By Nov. 13, Gabrysch had announced her resignation, citing concerns over maintaining her integrity and prompting calls from alders for investigations.

Mayoral response: The Johnson administration countered with calls to investigate Gabrysch for not attending recent meetings and prematurely transferring a $75 million pension payment.
- The mayor told Axios on Saturday that neither he nor his team had ever encouraged Gabrysch to present inaccurate data.
- On Tuesday, Johnson shrugged off the discrepancy as a "technical" dispute.
Between the lines: Forty-five (out of 50) alders appeared to view it as more than technical Wednesday when they voted for the probe, which they insisted "is not a financial audit."
What they're saying: "It's an attempt to review information, statements, meetings, memos and discussions with staff members regarding the creation of the budget and bonds," Finance Committee chair Ald. Pat Dowell said Wednesday.
- It's a "granular review of all the messaging around our financial position," Ald. Brendan Reilly said, "including emails and draft PowerPoints … to assure there's been no attempt to obfuscate or hide the facts."
- Dowell says the probe could include public testimony from Gabrysch.
Yes, but: Mayoral supporters, including Alds. Byron Sigcho-Lopez and Jason Ervin, characterized the probe as a waste of money, a "kangaroo court" and theatrics.
- Johnson's office issued a post-vote statement suggesting it sees the review as simply a financial audit, saying: "The administration welcomes an independent audit of the City's finances in accordance with professionally accepted standards."
- Axios asked the mayor's office for a response to the alders' plans to investigate communications rather than simply finances but did not get a response.
The council Wednesday also approved measures to:
- Urge the Illinois General Assembly to enact a millionaire's tax after Chicago voters overwhelmingly supported it in two referendums.
- Make the city secure a new gunshot detection system, also after robust referendum support.
- Audit how the city's license plate reader contractors manage the data it collects, especially under the state's TRUST Act.
