Public defenders offer fix for police settlements
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Illustration: Maura Losch/Axios
Amid all the disagreements in City Hall these days, there's one thing most agree on: The millions the city keeps paying for Chicago police abuse settlements reflect tragedies that should never happen again.
Why it matters: Officials at the Cook County Public Defender's Office have proposed a simple idea that could help prevent the kinds of false confessions plaintiffs say former detective Reynaldo Guevara coerced from them, recently costing the city $260 million.
The proposal: To give every arrestee immediate access to a phone and the public defender's hotline while being read their rights.
What they're saying: This "has the potential to create meaningful safeguards against wrongful convictions by curbing the conditions that allow for instances of coercion and misconduct while saving taxpayer dollars by reducing costly litigation stemming from wrongful convictions," Mayor Brandon Johnson's office tells Axios.
- "Accordingly, the Mayor has advised the Department of Law to explore how the City could implement this measure and make lawyers more accessible to people in CPD custody."
How it works: "The Cook County public defender operates a team of lawyers ready to respond 24 hours a day, seven days a week, for anyone who calls the hotline of our Arrest Response Division," ARD associate director Abigail Clough and Cook County Public Defender Sharone Mitchell wrote in a recent Tribune op-ed.
- "Attorneys at the station can meet with their clients immediately, offer legal advice when they most need it and prevent abuse or manipulation by the police."
Stunning stats: Ninety-one percent of people interrogated by CPD for the most serious crimes in 2023 and 2024 did not consult with a lawyer.
- Half (52%) did not get a phone call within three hours, according to an analysis by Northwestern University Pritzker School of Law professor Kyle Rozema.
The other side: Neither the Chicago Police Department nor the president of the Chicago Fraternal Order of Police, John Catanzara, responded to Axios requests for comment on the proposal.
The intrigue: Ald. Ray Lopez, a frequent police settlement critic and defender of the CPD, told Axios he would support the change.
- "I have no issue with ensuring all constitutional rights are made known and offered to a person being questioned or arrested. However, there are other legislative fixes needed concerning settlement caps and judicial fixes for distribution of guilt that also would be helpful moving forward."
What's next: "We believe the city of Chicago could implement this policy tomorrow if they choose to," public defender's law office spokesperson Matt Hendrickson tells Axios.
- "And we're pleased that Mayor Brandon Johnson has voiced support for our plan, which could save taxpayers hundreds of millions of dollars from wrongful convictions and prevent untold damage to families without spending a cent."
What we're watching: If and when the city will act.
