Jul 2, 2023 - Food and Drink

Food Fight: Where to find Chicago's best cookies

Three jars of different flavors of cookies.

Same Day Cafe in Logan Square. Photo: Justin Kaufmann/Axios

As Cookie Monster says, "Me want cookies!"

  • And we want all the scrumptious treats Axios Chicago readers recommended after we shared our own favorites last week.

Here's a hot batch of top picks and readers' favorites:

Same Day Cafe

2651 N Kedzie Ave. — Logan Square

Justin's pick: The diner offers great sandwiches, but don't sleep on the brown butter brown sugar cookies ($3).

  • The cafe serves up a few kinds of cookies, including a double chocolate, ginger molasses and peanut butter.
  • They aren't pricey for how big the cookie is.

Corey's NYC Bagel Deli

Locations in River North and Lincoln Park

Photo of a cookie on a counter.
Photo: Carrie Shepherd/Axios

Carrie's pick: The black-and-white cookie ($3.99) from Corey's NYC Bagel Deli, which despite its name is actually a Chicago-based chain.

  • The cookie is almost like yellow cake. It's spongy and moist, not hard and crumbly.
  • White frosting covers the entire cookie, and then black frosting is layered on top of half, making sure the whole thing is frosted. Note I said frosting, which tastes creamier than just icing.

Palermo Bakery

7312 W. Irving Park Rd., Norridge

Monica's pick: Even as a sweets-hater, I hold a soft spot for the amaretti ($16.95/lb) — made with egg whites and fine almond paste — at this Norridge bakery.

  • Flourless, soft, chewy and not too sweet, these Italian classics — especially when topped with more nuts — pair beautifully with a nice bitter cup of espresso.

Readers' favorite cookies

Sawada: Richard W. suggests the peanut butter cookie with chocolate icing ($3.50) sold at this popular West Loop coffee spot but baked at 3 Greens Bakery.

woman eating cookie, wearing sunglasses
Carrie and Justin can attest to the peanut better and chocolate AND the sprinkles cookie at Sawada. Photo: Justin Kaufmann/Axios

Giardino del Dolce: Pietro T. vouches for the the mini cannoli ($1.95) from this Northwest Side bakery on "Arlem Avenu."

Six cannolis covered in powdered sugar with pistachio and cream filling.
Photo courtesy of Giardino Del Dolce.

Tony's Deli: It's no Dinkel's (R.I.P.), but Carter O. says his kid "loses her mind" over the black-and-white cookies ($4) at this Lakeview bagel shop that ships in par-cooked bagels, and the cookies are baked in, um, New York.

Black and white cookie in saran wrap on tiled counter.
Black and White Cookie at Tony's (Taste of New York) Deli. Photo: Monica Eng/Axios

Summer House Santa Monica: Tony T. went all caps to say the cookies in this Lincoln Park bakery case are AMAZING. "The sea salt chocolate chip ($3.95) has the perfect balance of salty and sweet!"

Chocolate chip cookie with sea salt.
Chocolate chip cookie from Summer House Santa Monica. Photo: Monica Eng/Axios

River and Roads Cafe: Mountain-shaped cookies? Yes, please! Jamie T. says the cafe in Rogers Park has flavors from chocolate chip to chocolate chip caramel pretzel ($6).

cookies
Rivers and Roads cookies. Photo: Courtesy of Janine Ramirez.

Tempesta Market: Nathaniel K. says the West Town market "definitely has the best chocolate chip ($3.50) in the city!"

Beatrix: Meghan P.'s review of the butterscotch cookie ($4.90) is 😘. "Oatmeal gives it a chewy but soft texture, butterscotch is sweet and creamy, and the real key to this cookie's power is the sea salt top making it salty and sweet."

cookie
Butterscotch oatmeal cookie from Beatrix. Photo: Courtesy of Beatrix.

Levain: The bakery started in NYC and came to the West Loop last fall. Barb P. loves the thick, chunky cookies ($5) and the community-driven sensibility of the owners.

Photo: Justin Kaufmann/Axios

avatar

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Chicago.

More Chicago stories