Why Portland's participatory budgeting measure failed
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Photo illustration: Lindsey Bailey/Axios
Participatory budgeting gives residents a say in how public money is spent, but it failed to win over Portlanders in the midterm election earlier this month.
The big picture: The city's ongoing budgetary woes, concerns about how the measure would work and opposition from city leaders likely contributed to the defeat of Measure 26-267, aka the "Your 2 Cents" initiative.
- Still, supporters say they haven't given up on the idea.
- "Our biggest obstacle was the cynicism and gloom gripping Portlanders of all political stripes right now," Devin Ruiz, deputy director of Next Up Action Fund, a campaign partner and supporter, told Axios.
Catch up quick: The proposal would have required the city to amend the charter and set aside at least 2% of its discretionary budget — roughly $16 million annually — for community projects proposed and selected by residents.
- Nearly 63% of voters rejected the proposal in the Nov. 3 election.
State of play: Several factors may have contributed to its defeat, Frankline Muthomi, a Portland State University assistant professor who researches participatory budgeting, told Axios.
- By requiring at least 2% of the city's discretionary spending, regardless of financial circumstances, the proposal left little room to adjust funding if there are future budget shortfalls, he said.
- A more flexible approach, such as allocating up to 2% may have garnered broader support from officials, Muthomi said.
Plus: The measure left important implementation details unresolved, too, including how projects would be selected and by whom, as well as how the program would fit into the city's existing budgeting process.
- Muthomi said testing the concept — perhaps piloting it in a single city bureau — before putting it before voters could have helped address uncertainties.
- Mayor Keith Wilson and several labor unions opposed the measure, warning it could jeopardize funding for essential services.
What they're saying: Ruiz said Wilson's "defeatist campaign against the measure" didn't help, but supporters remain open to working with city leaders to bring participatory budgeting to Portland.
Meanwhile, the campaign tapped hyperlocal social media influencers as a way to connect with "younger and more infrequent voters," an approach Ruiz said paid off, pointing to the more than 107,000 Portlanders who supported the measure.
- "Those are the people City Hall rarely hears from, and that's exactly who participatory budgeting is for."
- Campaign finance records show the campaign received more than $900,000 in in-kind contributions designated for online and social media advertising.
What's next: Neither Ruiz nor Muthomi sees the measure's defeat as a rejection of participatory budgeting altogether. Both see a path forward.
- Muthomi said the process can strengthen civic engagement, but future efforts should bring together city officials, community members and advocates early in the process to talk about how it would fit in the current budgeting process.
- Ruiz said the coalition is interested in working with incoming Multnomah County Chair Shannon Singleton, who supported the measure, to explore bringing participatory budgeting to the county.
