Philly's latest trash fight pits Parker against progressives
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Zulene Mayfield, an activist at Chester Residents Concerned for Quality Living, walks near the Reworld incineration center. Photo: Caroline Gutman for the Washington Post via Getty Images
Philly progressives are planting their flag on Chester's garbage heaps.
Why it matters: The city's latest trash fight pits Mayor Cherelle Parker against progressive lawmakers over long-debated environmental concerns about burning trash.
The big picture: Activists have been beating the drum for years over Reworld's waste-to-energy plant in Chester, where an estimated third of Philly's trash is burned.
- Progressive Councilmember Jamie Gauthier has championed their cause, introducing legislation last year that would have stopped Philly from burning its trash.
- But she pulled the bill before a vote because she lacked enough support from city lawmakers and realized Parker was likely to veto it.
- Now, she's pivoted to rallying support against the city's contract with Reworld.
Driving the news: City Council is holding a hearing Wednesday at 1pm at City Hall to hear from environmental activists and Chester leaders, including Mayor Stefan Roots and Mike Ewall, founder of the Energy Justice Network.
- The hearing could help decide whether the city renews a proposed four-year contract with Reworld, which burns an estimated 400,000 tons of Philly trash every year in Chester, per Gauthier's office.
Zoom in: Gauthier's office has spent months preparing for the hearing, compiling a dossier provided to Axios that pulls information from public records requests and court records.
The dossier outlines that the company has:
- Racked up more than 400 violations at its facilities since 2005, including 33 violations of the federal Clean Air Act, resulting in more than $1 million in fines.
- Been involved in an ongoing lawsuit with a former employee who claims he was fired for refusing to falsify chemical filter settings so the incinerator would pass inspection.
What they're saying: Gauthier tells Axios that city lawmakers must decide whether to "chart a cleaner, greener, and healthier path."
- "Or we can condemn Philly and Chester to seven more years of toxic air and ash. I urge my colleagues to vote against Mayor Parker's dirty deal with trash incinerators."
The other side: Reworld tells Axios in a statement that emissions at its Chester facility are "up to 99% below" federal guidelines.
- Any decision on the contract should be "grounded in transparent data, credible science and measurable environmental outcomes, not fear-based rhetoric or misinformation."
- The contract is the "most cost-efficient proposal" for city taxpayers while it works toward a longer-term plan that "offers a real solution to reduce waste and protect the environment," city spokesperson Keisha McCarty tells Axios.
Catch up quick: Parker has done an about-face on the Chester plant.
- She went from blasting an opponent over his disregard for the issue on the campaign trail to her administration endorsing a new contract with Reworld as "environmentally safe."
- Gauthier, who took part in a tour last year highlighting the facility's impact on Chester, believes the city should instead send its trash to area landfills — not ideal but less environmentally harmful.
Reality check: It's hard to figure out exactly how much Philly has paid Reworld for disposing of its trash since the city pays the company per ton.
- Gauthier's office estimates Philly paid Reworld $15 million in 2025.
By the numbers: Philly's latest proposal would pay Reworld between $47 and $72 per ton of trash in 2027, depending on which of its Pennsylvania facilities handles the waste, per a copy obtained by Axios.
- The rates will jump to $56 to $86 per ton by 2033.
What we're watching: Whether the contract advances out of committee.
- City lawmakers could vote to approve the deal as early as Dec. 3.
