Apr 18, 2024 - News

Arizona GOP Rep. Austin Smith ends campaign amid forgery allegations

Illustration of an elephant walking through an exit door.

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

Arizona Republicans will have to rely on a write-in campaign to hold a state House seat after first-term incumbent Rep. Austin Smith (R-Surprise) ended his campaign following allegations that signatures on his nominating petitions were forged.

Why it matters: The GOP is trying to maintain its one-vote House majority this year, and it can't afford to concede any safe districts.

Zoom in: Each district elects two at-large representatives. Only two Republicans — Smith and fellow incumbent Rep. Steve Montenegro — filed to run in the West Valley-based Legislative District 29.

  • Two Democrats are also in the race for the overwhelmingly Republican district.
  • In his announcement, Smith said James Taylor, a lifelong Republican who worked at the Palo Verde Generating Station for nearly 30 years, has agreed to run as a write-in.

Catch up quick: Democrats filed a legal challenge to Smith's candidacy this week alleging a number of his petition sheets contain signatures "that appear to have been written by the same person" and that many "bear a striking resemblance" to Smith's own handwriting.

  • The complaint included affidavits from two voters stating they didn't sign Smith's petition, even though their names appear on it.
  • State law mandates that all petitions submitted by a candidate found guilty of forgery shall be disqualified, and that the candidate is ineligible to run for office for five years.

Threat level: If Taylor or another write-in Republican doesn't receive enough primary votes, the GOP won't be able to win both safe seats.

  • Write-in primary candidates must get a number of votes equal to or greater than the number of signatures they would've needed to normally qualify for the ballot.
  • For Republicans in District 29, that number is 527.

What he's saying: In a statement on X, Smith on Thursday denied forging signatures and called the complaint part of an "intense effort" by the Democrats to "get me."

  • He said some allegedly forged signatures were for Democratic voters, and questioned why anyone would forge the signatures of Democrats not eligible to sign Republican petitions.
  • But rather than spend thousands on legal fees and risk a judge falsely finding that he'd committed forgery, he said, he's ending his campaign.
  • "I might be confident of victory, but all it would take is a judge believing any one person, and all would be lost," he said.

Context: Smith is a member of the far-right Arizona Freedom Caucus and a top official at Turning Point Action, the campaign arm of the campus conservative organization Turning Point USA.

What's next: Secretary of State Adrian Fontes has referred the complaint to the attorney general for forgery or fraud allegations, spokesperson Aaron Thacker told Axios.

The other side: Democrats are facing a similar situation in a safely blue district.

  • Rep. Melody Hernandez (D-Tempe) ended her state Senate campaign Monday after a Republican complaint alleged she didn't qualify because she didn't have enough valid signatures and had too many outstanding campaign finance fines.

Editor's note: This story has been updated to include the news of Smith's resignation from Turning Point Action.


Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Phoenix.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Phoenix stories

No stories could be found


Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Phoenix.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more