Metro legal director says changing the charter related to council size requires voter approval
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Illustration: Allie Carl/Axios
Metro's top lawyer told a council committee last week that state law requires voters to approve any changes to the charter related to the number of Metro Council members.
Why it matters: The critical legal analysis from director of law Tyler Yarbro calls into question if there is enough time for Metro to abide by the state law that slashes the size of the council.
Nate's analysis: This is a thorny legal situation, even for lawyers and Metro nerds.
- Here's the gist: The Supreme Court upheld the controversial 2023 law that caps the size of the council at no more than 20 members. Council is going to be reduced; there's no way around that. However, the law doesn't prescribe a timeline for when the reduction must take place.
- Stay with me now, because we're going to pivot from state to city laws. Metro's charter contains references to the number of council districts and countywide at-large members. Yarbro told the council's charter committee that existing state law says only voters can approve the changes necessary to fix the charter and abide by the new law.
- That means the earliest a measure related to the size of the council could be in front of voters is August 2027. Under that scenario, the council wouldn't be reduced until 2031.
Yes, but: Council could decide to propose a charter amendment and put it on the ballot in a special election earlier in 2027.
Friction point: If they don't choose this option, then Republican state lawmakers could pass legislation tweaking the law and force the city's hand.
- There's an unspoken tension as council navigates this, because council members have a political motivation to kick the can until 2031. Incumbent members almost never lose reelection bids.
- Keeping the number at 40 for the next term goes a long way toward securing reelection.
Fun fact: Voters pondered a charter amendment a decade ago to reduce the size of the council to 24 and rejected the plan.
- Nashville likes its enormous city council, mainly because it makes the local lawmakers more accessible.
What's next: Council is planning a series of listening sessions across the city to get feedback from residents about how to reduce the council.
- The biggest questions are how many district members and how many at-large members the council should have. New district boundaries must also be drawn.
