Apr 23, 2024 - Politics

Tennessee's universal voucher push implodes

Illustration of a lit fuse as the stem of an apple.

Illustration: Lindsey Bailey/Axios

Gov. Bill Lee confirmed his fight to expand school vouchers statewide in Tennessee has ended in defeat, at least for now.

Why it matters: Lee has spent years championing vouchers, which allow families to use state money to pay tuition at private schools. Taking the model statewide was a top priority for 2024.

  • The plan's implosion despite a Republican supermajority shows that an influx of money from pro-voucher groups has not beat back bipartisan skepticism.

Driving the news: Tennessee's House and Senate advanced widely different versions of the plan. The House included extra funding for public school priorities, while the Senate favored a more stripped-down approach.

  • Ultimately, the two chambers couldn't come to a consensus.
  • Multiple outlets reported negotiations had fallen apart last week. Lee acknowledged it in a statement, saying he was "extremely disappointed."

What he's saying: "While we made tremendous progress, unfortunately it has become clear that there is not a pathway for the bill during this legislative session," Lee said.

Flashback: Vouchers were top of mind for the Lee administration from his first days in office in 2019. A measure to create a voucher program passed narrowly that year after it was tailored to apply only in Davidson and Shelby counties.

  • A small-scale expansion to Hamilton County passed last year.
  • Lee announced his plan for a statewide program in November.

Between the lines: Local school leaders from across the state and the political spectrum roundly opposed the universal expansion push, saying it would sap money from public schools.

  • Lee and other proponents said it would give families options for school settings that would best suit their children.

State of play: While lawmakers didn't rally behind a plan for voucher expansion, they did still include $144 million meant to fund statewide vouchers in this year's budget. That money will sit unused.

  • Democratic state Sen. Raumesh Akbari said Monday that "instead of throwing millions into a program that isn't effective," lawmakers should put more money toward public schools.

What's next: Lee's statement said Republican leaders would revive the voucher expansion when they return to work in 2025. The Tennessee Journal noted the political playing field might have changed a bit by then.

  • The Journal reported five House Republicans are retiring this year, while 12 more face primary challengers in August.

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Nashville.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Nashville stories


Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Nashville.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more