Mar 5, 2024 - News

Florida beach renourishment stalemate hits another roadblock

Sandy dunes blocked off with pink tape and a sign that says "KEEP OFF DUNES."

Dunes on Sunset Beach are blocked off for a Pinellas County-led restoration project after Hurricane Idalia. Photo: Kathryn Varn/Axios

The latest effort to end a yearslong stalemate between local and federal governments over beach renourishment has itself stalled.

Why it matters: Beach renourishment — the process of pumping sand onto shorelines to combat erosion — keeps Florida's beaches accessible to the public and protects waterfront habitats and communities from storms.

  • Such projects are expensive, running up tabs in the tens of millions; without federal help, renourishment could be out of reach for some locales.

Catch up quick: City and county governments have for decades partnered with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers to split the work and cost.

  • But the Corps recently reinterpreted its own rules governing how to access privately owned land through an agreement called an easement.
  • The Corps now requires that all property owners within a beach renourishment project area grant public access to some of their land in perpetuity.
  • The new standard has put three Pinellas County projects on hold indefinitely, leaving local officials desperate for a solution.

The latest: At the start of this year's legislative session, three Pinellas lawmakers filed legislation urging Congress to direct the Corps to change its policy.

Yes, but: Bureaucracy struck again. While House Memorial 1411 had bipartisan support and was purely symbolic, it won't get a vote before this session ends on Friday, co-sponsor Rep. Lindsay Cross, D-St. Petersburg, told Axios.

  • In other words, the legislation is dead.

What they're saying: "The failure of leadership to put this on the floor is not the right decision because it affects so many of our constituents — and our tourism," Cross said Monday.

The other side: A spokesperson for House Speaker Paul Renner's office did not return Axios' request for comment.

Zoom in: Pinellas County's biggest project on hold is the Sand Key renourishment project, which covers about 14 miles from south of Sand Key Park to North Redington Beach.

  • Pinellas officials have obtained less than half — 223 of 461 — of the required easements, county spokesperson Tony Fabrizio told Axios.
  • Another 15 are needed for smaller projects in St. Pete Beach and Treasure Island.
  • A district commander for the Army Corps has spoken to concerned homeowners and "forwarded those concerns to our headquarters for their consideration," per a statement shared with Axios.

What's next: Members of Florida's congressional delegation are aware of the problem and working on solutions, Florida Shore and Beach Preservation Association president Pepper Uchino told Axios.

  • "It is vitally important that we get this right," Uchino said. If the federal partnership breaks down, "Florida would have to pick up the tab, or beaches would continue to erode."

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Tampa Bay.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Tampa Bay stories

No stories could be found

Tampa Baypostcard

Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Tampa Bay.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more