Richmond's ICE protections leave key questions unanswered
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
The crowd at the launch of the policy on Monday included RPS superintendent Jason Kamras and police chief Rick Edwards. Photo: Sabrina Moreno/Axios
Richmond is formally limiting how city employees and police can cooperate with federal immigration enforcement.
Why it matters: The policy aims to reassure immigrants they can seek city services without fear of being reported to ICE, but key safeguards meant to hold the city accountable are still being developed.
Driving the news: After years of pressure from immigrant advocates, officials unveiled the long-awaited trust policy Monday — joining a handful of Virginia localities like Fairfax and Arlington with similar rules.
- Much of the policy formalizes existing practices, but Mayor Avula said it clarifies expectations for employees and residents.
- The policy comes after Richmond saw a sharp decline in 911 calls last year as immigration enforcement intensified, though Avula said those declines have since leveled off.
What to know: City employees generally can't ask about residents' immigration status, share it with federal authorities, or assist with civil immigration enforcement, with some legal exceptions, per an internal policy copy obtained by Axios.
- Police can't stop or detain people solely over their immigration status or federal civil immigration warrants or detainers.
- Residents don't need to prove legal status to access most local services, including police, libraries and emergency assistance.
Yes, but: Richmond hasn't established a way for residents to report violations or penalties for employees who break the rules — though Avula said they could include termination.
- Violations must be reported internally, but specific disciplinary procedures haven't been finalized yet.
- Officials say they're developing those accountability measures and success metrics with input from community leaders.
Reality check: The policy doesn't stop ICE from conducting enforcement operations, and some federally funded services still require immigration documentation.
- It also doesn't cover the independently elected Richmond sheriff, whose office oversees the city jail.
- Avula said he hasn't heard whether Sheriff Antionette Irving will provide annual data on interactions with federal immigration authorities.
- The sheriff's office didn't immediately respond to Axios' request for comment.
What's next: The city must present regulations to council by Jan. 1, but Avula wants the policy fully implemented by year's end, including mandatory employee training.
- The policy is also being translated into seven languages: Spanish, French, Arabic, Chinese, Korean, Vietnamese and Brazilian Portuguese.