Downtown YMCA demolition on hold after historic preservation hearing
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

The shuttered Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA building on First Avenue north of Van Buren Street. Photo: Jeremy Duda/Axios
Wrecking balls won't be slamming into the Lincoln Family Downtown YMCA in Phoenix anytime soon after the city's Historic Preservation Commission voted Monday to pursue zoning protection for the structure.
Why it matters: It's a stay of execution for the 74-year-old building, which was to be demolished for a $60 million new facility — though the commission's decision may not lead to its reopening.
Catch up quick: The downtown YMCA officially shut its doors Sept. 30, displacing scores of residents who lived there.
- Last month, the organization announced plans for a modern new home for the Y on the same lot, with millions in funding from the Suns and Mercury.
Driving the news: After the commission voted to explore historic preservation zoning — passing it 3-2 with two abstentions — the building is on a year-long demolition hold.
- At the hearing, several commissioners expressed frustration that the YMCA had not consulted them before moving forward with a plan to scrap the old building and construct a new one.
- While the YMCA can demolish the building at the end of the demolition hold no matter the zoning, the commission hopes the pause prompts the organization to consider other options.
What they're saying: "Some people, they look at that building … and they don't think that it's 'historic' because it doesn't look like the old City Hall building or whatever," commission chair Tricia Amato tells Axios. "But it is historic."
The other side: John Graham, who serves on the board of directors for the Valley of the Sun YMCA, says the building cannot be renovated and preserved.
- The residential portion of the building has ceilings that are too low, rooms that are too small and out-of-date communal bathrooms, Graham says.
- "The pool is absolutely not fixable," he adds, "and then there's a lot of the spaces in the basement, which is like a dungeon."
- The new facility would feature three basketball courts (instead of one) as well as 57 new housing units.
How it works: The city's Historic Preservation Office (HPO) will now study the building more closely and make a final recommendation to the commission, per preservation officer Helana Ruter.
- The city could hire a structural engineer who is trained in historic buildings.
- If the building is deemed to be at legitimate risk of failing structurally, HPO could recommend allowing its teardown.
- Yes, but: "Since it's been operating up until a month ago, it wouldn't appear to be one that was in danger of immediately collapsing," Ruter says.
What's next: The YMCA will appeal the commission's decision to the City Council, Graham says — though should that be denied, "We just lose a Y downtown. We have no plan B."
- The $60 million for a new facility is tied to that particular site and would not be repurposed to build somewhere else, he adds.
- "Unequivocally, we will not renovate that facility. It's a safety problem. It's dysfunctional," he says. "Plus, all that money that people are giving us, they wouldn't give us a dime to do that."
