Questions surround $5B Washington Square Mall pitch
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Photo: Justin L. Mack/Axios
A Los Angeles-based developer is pitching a multibillion-dollar plan to transform Washington Square Mall into a 2,000-room luxury resort destination.
Why it matters: The high-cost concept faces unresolved questions about site control while lacking public backing from key stakeholders.
The big picture: The nearly 94-acre far east side site is one of Indianapolis' biggest redevelopment opportunities, but the latest pitch raises concerns about financing, ownership and whether the vision aligns with neighborhood priorities.
Driving the news: BRC Commercial Properties outlined its proposed Washington Square Grand Hotel, Resort and Conference Center at a public meeting Thursday night.
- Preliminary plans called for luxury amenities, conference facilities, entertainment attractions and other hospitality offerings.
- The proposal is conceptual, but BRC estimates it would cost $5 billion.
Context: A community-backed plan unveiled in August by City-County Councilor Michael-Paul Hart and Schmidt Associates envisions a mixed-use neighborhood with retail, restaurants, recreation, green space and housing.
- The flexible blueprint was designed to attract investors, not lock in a final design. No developer or construction timeline had been secured at the time.
Friction point: BRC chief operating officer Eddie Hager previously told Axios the company had a pending purchase agreement with the mall's majority owner, Durga Property Holdings.
- He added that BRC had been working on that agreement for "nearly two years" at the time.
- But Durga representatives disputed the status of that deal in February when plans to study the site were announced, and again during Thursday's presentation.
- In a blog post published Sunday, Hart said the BRC presentation could actually make Washington Square's revival more difficult. Ahead of last week's meeting, he told IBJ that he is not involved in the company's plans and does not want to be.
What they're saying: "A serious developer needs a path to controlling the land, an understanding of the zoning and a realistic financing plan," Hart wrote. "Announcing a massive project before doing that work can actually make redevelopment harder. Our own study warns that public announcements before land assembly can drive up property prices."
Follow the money: Hart has said redevelopment of the site will require private investment and a mix of public tools, including tax-increment financing, grants and tax credits.
- The census tract surrounding Washington Square was nominated for federal Opportunity Zone designation, a potential incentive for private investment. Treasury certification is still pending.
Flashback: Washington Square opened in 1974 as an eastern Marion County shopping destination.
- Years of anchor store departures, changing shopping habits and deferred maintenance left much of the property struggling.
- Target and AMC remain open, and the broader site has multiple property owners, complicating redevelopment.
What's next: BRC must turn its pitch into a financeable project with site control and a clearer path forward.
- The central question for residents is whether that future delivers the neighborhood benefits they've been asking for.