Jul 15, 2022 - Things to Do

Our favorite places to thrift shop in Columbus

Illustration of a clothes hanger resembling a recycling icon

Illustration: Annelise Capossela/Axios

Central Ohio shoppers on the hunt for savings and sustainability have lots of options thanks to our thriving thrift store scene.

Why it matters: Amid inflation and growing concerns about fast fashion's climate impact, buying secondhand is an easy way to save money, lower your carbon footprint and discover unique items.

State of play: 93% of U.S. shoppers have or are open to buying secondhand products, up from 70% in 2019, Axios' Hope King reports.

Percentage who say they have bought or are willing to buy secondhand products
Data: GlobalData; Chart: Baidi Wang/Axios

How it works: Thrift stores range from places that accept and sell almost anything, like Goodwill and Salvation Army, to high-end consignment shops.

  • Many will buy your goods to resell.

Some of our local favorites:

🖼️ For trinkets and decor: One More Time Etc., with a fashion shop a few storefronts away.

  • Grandview Heights.

🎮 For games and movies: VGMX, the self-proclaimed "nerd emporium."

  • Northland.

👕 For a good cause: Out of the Closet, with proceeds benefiting the AIDS Healthcare Foundation.

  • Short North.

👗 If you like things neatly organized: Clothes Mentor, Alissa's go-to for dresses and cheap Chuck Taylors.

  • Multiple locations.

💪 If you don't mind getting dirty: Goodwill Outlet, where you can dig through unsorted bins for buried treasures sold by the pound.

  • Far East Side.

💭 Alissa's thought bubble: Thrifting is all about the thrill of the hunt. If you keep an open mind, you never know what you'll find.

  • I snagged a retired Thomas Kinkade puzzle of my favorite movie, "The Little Mermaid," for just $7 at Volunteers of America on Indianola Avenue. this week. Brand new!
  • Thanks to reader Mark M. for the suggestion!
An Ohio-shaped Jim Beam bottle that reads "The Wonderful World of Ohio" above the state seal
If you're looking for Ohio-themed decor, One More Time Etc. is selling this Jim Beam bottle from the '60s for $15. Does anyone know why it exists? Photo: Alissa Widman Neese/Axios

🛍 Bonus: Your thrifting picks

Mark M.: "St. Vincent de Paul's on East Main Street past 270. Monday through Wednesday they have tag colors on sale."

Challen B.: "ABSOLUTELY Second Chance in Grandview — best thrift store! Probably 80% of my wardrobe comes from there."

Jane H.: "One More Time in Grandview. I’ve scored Prada and Missoni off their designer rack (usually near the back). Eileen Fisher items usually are hidden in the regular racks."

Rebecca E.: Ohio Thrift and Volunteers of America on West Broad Street and Goodwill on Renner Road.

Joyce C.: Heritage Square Antique Mall at Brice Road & Livingston Avenue.

  • "I still can’t believe a lot of people don’t know about it. A wide variety of vendors. Sylvia’s A-Z Closet, space C-33, a hidden gem."

📬 Want to add your favorite to our list? Email [email protected].


Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Columbus.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Columbus stories

No stories could be found


Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Columbus.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more