Indigenous organizers, Plymouth clash again over Day of Mourning plans
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

People march in Plymouth during the National Day of Mourning protest on Nov. 28, 2024. Photo: Joseph Prezioso/AFP via Getty Images
A Native American coalition wants to take Plymouth back to court, accusing the town of blocking its efforts to convene on Coles Hill for the National Day of Mourning.
The big picture: The Massachusetts town and Wampanoag people, whose ancestors lived in the area long before the town's founding, continue to clash over an event held on Thanksgiving that confronts the genocide and discrimination in the years following the 1621 feast.
Catch up quick: At the center of the dispute is a 1998 agreement between the town and the United American Indians of New England (UAINE) over the Day of Mourning, which the group has observed since 1970.
- The agreement confirmed UAINE could continue holding the event every year, following a violent clash with police a year earlier.
- Last November, UAINE took Plymouth to court after officials declined to set up the stage on Coles Hill unless the organizers obtained permits and liability insurance.
- Town attorneys argued, unsuccessfully, that the agreement can't dictate the event details in perpetuity and asked to amend the deal.
- They reached a settlement two days before the march and federal holiday to let the event continue, but Plymouth town officials are again imposing insurance and permit requirements.
Driving the news: UAINE accused Plymouth of violating the agreement and infringing on members' First Amendment rights, voting on Nov. 10 to stop complying with the agreement, per court documents filed Monday.
- The vote occurred during executive session, the Plymouth Independent reported.
What they're saying: "Plymouth clearly cares more about preserving the 'America's Hometown' fantasy it has created for itself than it cares about freedom of speech or meeting its obligations to UAINE under the 1998 agreement," Kisha James, co-leader of UAINE, said in a statement.
- James, a member of the Wampanoag Tribe of Gay Head (Aquinnah), was referring to the annual "America's Hometown Thanksgiving Parade," held the Saturday before Thanksgiving.
- Other Wampanoag members and allies, including descendants of colonists, expressed outrage over the requirements and the executive-session vote at a meeting Tuesday night.
The other side: Select Board Chair Deb Iaquinto said Tuesday that the town supports the Day of Mourning, and that it has been in talks with organizers for months.
- "It makes us look like the bad guys, but we require every other group to provide insurance," Iaquinto told the Independent. "The town is between a rock and a hard place."
- Select Board members and Town Manager Derek Brindisi did not respond to multiple calls and emails from Axios seeking comment.
Zoom in: UAINE said in court documents that the town has repeatedly changed its reasons for opposing the agreement in recent years, most recently arguing that Coles Hill was state property.
- The state Department of Conservation and Recreation, which owns the land, told the town and organizers on Nov. 5 that it had no problem with the event or with the town erecting a stage, per UAINE's court filings.
- DCR did not respond to questions emailed by Axios Wednesday.
What we're watching: Organizers have barely a week to reach a resolution with the town before the National Day of Mourning.
