The uphill fight for a SNAP fraud hearing in Massachusetts
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Maura Kearns/Axios
Deehan here with Spill of the Hill, my column unraveling Massachusetts politics.
Massachusetts GOP senators are trying to get the state to cough up more information about potential benefit fraud.
Why it matters: It's tricky political ground for the genteel and mostly moderate Republicans of the state Senate.
- Policing wasteful public spending is the GOP's bread-and-butter in Massachusetts, but the national debate around SNAP fraud has smothered the issue in the type of hyper-partisan muck Senate Minority Leader Bruce Tarr usually tries to keep clean of.
State of play: Tarr and his Republican caucus late last month requested a hearing on SNAP fraud and dysfunction at the Department of Transitional Assistance.
What they're saying: Republicans cited recent reports of fraud in the state, a DTA whistleblower's claims that staff were instructed to go easy on migrant applicants and federal enforcement actions here and in other states against benefit fraud rings.
- "Taken together ... these developments present a clear pattern of systemic vulnerabilities that warrant immediate legislative oversight," the GOP caucus wrote.
The other side: Committee Chair Sen. Mark Montigny acknowledged the request, but didn't commit to a hearing.
- "As the U.S. Attorney recently made clear, her office continues to investigate 'many' cases of benefit fraud, and this committee is monitoring the situation very closely."
- Montigny did say the committee was working to investigate procurement practices at MassDOT and the convention center authority, dysfunction with the unemployment system and runaway utility company spending.
The latest: Auditor Diana DiZoglio's Bureau of Special Investigations last week reported $4.49 million in public benefit overpayments during the first half of fiscal year 2026.
- DiZoglio's team says they found fraud in over 17% of the cases they looked into.
By the numbers: SNAP accounted for $2.48 million and MassHealth for $1.72 million, according to the auditor's findings.
- The remaining cases involved transitional aid, personal care attendants and early education.
- She says the bureau documented more than $34 million in public benefits fraud over the last three years.
U.S. Attorney Leah Foley recently announced charges in a $1 million SNAP scheme involving more than 100 stolen identities. That's after a separate $7 million benefit bust in December.
The intrigue: The mounting findings come during an escalating fight between Gov. Maura Healey and the Trump administration over turning over SNAP recipient data, which could be used for immigration enforcement.
Zoom out: The extreme rhetoric from national Republicans regarding SNAP and benefit fraud isn't the Senate GOP's style.
Yes, but: Trying to force the Democrats who run the state to expose fraud and government waste is very much part of the Mass. GOP playbook, even when they sport dwarfish minorities in both legislative chambers.
The bottom line: An aggressive federal posture and mounting evidence of fraud may not be enough to sway Democrats to hold a hearing on SNAP unless they hear an outcry from voters.
- Those voters are likely to return Healey to office this fall and could even increase Democrats' margins in the General Court, so leaders on Beacon Hill don't have much incentive to look under the floorboards when it comes to SNAP fraud.