Why Somerville fired Mayor Ballantyne
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Somerville Mayor Katjana Ballantyne on July 17. Photo: Erin Clark/The Boston Globe via Getty Images
Somerville voters ousted Mayor Katjana Ballantyne from office after two terms, topped by two opponents who said she lacked responsive leadership in trying times.
Why it matters: Delivering city services still matters, even amid a nationalized political atmosphere.
- Ballantyne's defeat shows there's significant voter dissatisfaction, even in a progressive city facing high housing costs and federal pressure.
Catch up quick: Ballantyne received only about 24% of the preliminary election vote Tuesday, according to unofficial tallies, losing out to city councilors Jake Wilson (42%) and Willie Burnley Jr. (34%).
- It was a stunning rebuke to Ballantyne, who was first elected in 2021.
Between the lines: Incumbent mayors rarely lose re-election in Massachusetts, making Ballantyne's fall highly unusual.
Zoom in: Burnley and Wilson spent the campaign criticizing Ballantyne's accessibility and responsiveness to Somerville residents.
- Rodent problems, homelessness and interdepartmental conflicts at City Hall became campaign talking points.
- Wilson told the Boston Globe voters felt "closed off from their mayor," while basic city services declined despite the budget expanding.
The other side: Throughout her campaign, Ballantyne acknowledged voter frustration with cost-of-living challenges and the speed of tackling housing costs.
Zoom out: The upset mirrors broader anti-incumbent sentiment in Massachusetts and the rest of the country.
Yes, but: Boston Mayor Michelle Wu soundly defeated challenger Josh Kraft, who mounted a similar campaign strategy of criticizing City Hall dysfunction.
What's next: Wilson and Burnley will face off in November's general election.
- The next mayor will inherit challenges from Ballantyne's administration, including potential constraints and federal funding threats under the Trump administration.
The bottom line: Voters demanded more responsive government in Somerville, enough to overcome Ballantyne's incumbent advantage.