Americans have never trusted the Supreme Court less
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Americans' trust and confidence in the judicial branch has hit a new low as the Supreme Court prepares for a new term, according to Gallup.
The big picture: The justices return to the bench after spending their summer making consequential emergency-docket decisions allowing some (but not all) of President Trump's most controversial executive actions to proceed.
Driving the news: Since 2022, fewer than half of Americans have reported a great deal or a fair amount of trust and confidence in the judicial branch, headed by the Supreme Court — a share that had never dipped below 50% before in Gallup's trend stretching back to 1972.
- 54% reported having not very much trust and confidence or none at all.
- The slice who disapprove of how the Supreme Court is handling its job is tied for the record high — 61%, recorded in September and July of this year — while the share who approve has fallen under 35% for the second survey in a row.
Between the lines: The percentage who reported at least a fair amount of trust in the judicial branch slipped below half for the first time in Gallup's trend in September 2022, some three months after the justices voted to overturn Roe v. Wade.
- Democrats have largely driven the trust freefall, with those who have at least a fair about of trust and confidence down to 23%. In 2020, more than half (58%) shared that sentiment.
- Trust among independents has also plummeted by some 20 points, down to 42% today.
Yes, but: The Republican in the White House has been displeased with his own SCOTUS picks this term.
- Trump raged at the Supreme Court earlier this month for rejecting his mail-in voting rule rewrite, global tariffs and birthright citizenship policy, writing in a lengthy Truth Social post that "[t]hese are not the people I interviewed to serve on the United States Supreme Court."
- However, a plurality in Gallup's poll (43%) said the court was too conservative, while 17% said it was too liberal, and 35% said it was about right.
- While Trump didn't get his way on those three major cases, the Supreme Court has green-lit his stricter asylum rules, Temporary Protected Status revocations, White House ballroom construction, FTC firings and more in recent months.
What we're watching: The court will release an order list and hear its first oral arguments of the term on Monday in cases related to climate change and veterans' benefits.
- The justices may be starting a new term, but they aren't getting a clean slate in the court of public opinion.
