Axios Vitals

December 01, 2020
Good morning.
Join Axios today at 12:30pm ET for a World AIDS Day and Giving Tuesday virtual event featuring Every Mother Counts founder Christy Turlington Burns, ONE Campaign president and CEO Gayle E. Smith and Churches Health Association of Zambia head of Advocacy, Planning and Development Yoram Siame.
- Register here.
Today's word count is 977, or a 4-minute read.
1 big thing: The messiness of vaccine prioritization
Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios
Over the next few weeks, U.S. officials will be deciding who receives the first coronavirus vaccines, a dicey political decision with life-or-death implications.
Between the lines: There's a strong case for multiple populations to be at the front of the line, but limited vaccine supply means that governors will ultimately have to make tough decisions about who to prioritize.
Driving the news: The Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices, a committee that advises the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on vaccine policy, meets today to vote on who should be vaccinated first.
- The group has signaled that it will recommend that health care workers should be first, but top Trump administration health officials are pushing for adults 65 and older to be at the front of the line, STAT reports.
- "The conflicting views risk sending mixed signals to public health authorities at the state level," STAT's Helen Branswell writes.
Yes, but: States will ultimately make the decision, and governors are preparing to face one of the toughest moral choices they'll confront in office, Axios' Jonathan Swan reports.
- New Mexico Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham explained her nightmare scenario to Swan: The federal government gives her sufficient doses to initially vaccinate every nursing home resident and every hospital worker in her state, but not nearly enough to cover the one in three adults statewide with chronic disorders.
- "So I've got 700,000 people I need to start getting the vaccine to, and I get 25,000 doses," she said. "That will be hard."
The bottom line: Nearly four in 10 U.S. adults are considered at-risk of severe coronavirus infections because of their age or pre-existing health conditions, per KFF.
- They all have a strong case for being vaccinated early on. Not all of them can be.
2. FDA chief called to West Wing
White House Chief of Staff Mark Meadows has summoned FDA commissioner Stephen Hahn to the West Wing for a 9:30am meeting to explain why he hasn't moved faster to approve the Pfizer coronavirus vaccine, Jonathan reported last night.
Why it matters: The meeting is shaping up as a Battle Royale, with Hahn using kamikaze language in a preemptive statement: "Let me be clear — our career scientists have to make the decision and they will take the time that’s needed to make the right call on this important decision."
A senior administration official said that in mid-November, Hahn spent a week vacationing in the Outer Banks of North Carolina, and the official expected this subject would be discussed.
- "There are some who are complaining the FDA is not working around the clock to get things approved and because of that, Meadows has asked Dr. Hahn for a briefing," a sec0nd administration official said.
This official said Meadows wanted Hahn to explain why he was hearing that the FDA was not moving fast enough to greenlight the Pfizer vaccine, which was the first to be submitted for emergency agency approval.
- An FDA spokesperson denied Hahn was vacationing and responded: "Dr. Hahn was recently exposed to COVID while working at the FDA's White Oak campus. Dr. Hahn chose a remote location to quarantine and he continued working, as he has done throughout the pandemic. Dr. Hahn has worked every single day of this pandemic, including weekends, holidays and more."
3. Pandemic buzz words
Illustration: Eniola Odetunde/Axios
A new study finds that certain vocabulary is more effective at getting the public to take the coronavirus pandemic seriously, Axios' Sara Fischer reports.
Why it matters: "If we don't get this language right, people will die," veteran GOP pollster Frank Luntz tells Axios.
- Luntz argues whether it's being done intentionally or not, much of the language being used by the White House, local politicians, business leaders and the media to talk about the virus politicizes the issue, which is causing large swaths of the population to tune information about the pandemic out.
- The polling suggests that Republicans especially tend to take the virus less seriously, in part because the vocabulary used to describe safety measures feels invasive of their constitutional rights.
Driving the news: In a study he conducted in conjunction with the de Beaumont Foundation, Luntz finds that a few simple wording changes can make all the difference:
- Lockdowns: Respondents to the survey had a much more positive reaction to the term "a stay-at-home order" than a "lockdown."
- Safety measures: To that end, the data shows that Americans have a more positive reaction when rules and regulations to address COVID-19 are called "protocols" as opposed to "mandates," "directives," "controls," or "orders."
- Naming the virus: Leaders should use the word "pandemic" instead of "coronavirus," because it helps to humanize and personalize the virus. Overall, Americans consider a "pandemic" more "significant, serious, and scary" than "COVID-19" or coronavirus."
4. Coronavirus may have been in U.S. in Dec. 2019
The coronavirus was likely in the U.S. earlier than scientists initially believed — and weeks before it was officially identified in China, according to a study by government scientists published in Clinical Infectious Diseases.
The big picture: "The findings significantly strengthen evidence suggesting the virus was spreading around the world well before public health authorities and researchers became aware, upending initial thinking about how early and quickly it emerged," the Wall Street Journal reports.
Details: CDC scientists found evidence of coronavirus infection in blood samples collected by the American Red Cross from residents in nine states between Dec. 13 and Jan. 17.
- The scientists found antibodies in 39 samples from California, Oregon and Washington state collected between Dec. 13 and Dec. 16, and in 67 samples from Massachusetts, Michigan, Wisconsin or Iowa, and Connecticut or Rhode Island collected between Dec. 30 and Jan. 17.
- The first coronavirus case in the U.S. was reported on Jan. 19.
My thought bubble: Even though the pandemic has consumed our lives for the better part of a year, we still have so much to learn about it.
5. Catch up quick
Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios
Moderna filed with the FDA Monday for an emergency use authorization for its coronavirus vaccine, which the company said has an efficacy rate of 94.1%.
Scott Atlas, a controversial member of the White House coronavirus task force, handed in his resignation on Monday, according to three administration officials who discussed Atlas' resignation with Axios.
The TSA screened 1,176,091 people at checkpoints in the U.S. on Sunday, the highest number since mid-March, according to a spokesperson.
New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo said on Monday that struggling state hospital systems must transfer patients to sites that are not nearing capacity, as rising coronavirus cases and hospitalizations strain medical resources.
Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) returned to in-person work on Monday after quarantining with an asymptomatic case of the coronavirus, his office said in a statement.


