30 over 30: Red Key Tavern
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

The Red Key's neon lights are a staple in SoBro. Photo: Arika Herron/Axios
To step through the door at the Red Key Tavern is to step back into Indianapolis history.
Why it matters: Largely unchanged from the early 1950s, when Russ Settle bought the SoBro bar, the Red Key is part time capsule, part lesson in staying true to your roots as the world changes around you.
Flashback: 5170 N. College Avenue first opened its doors as a Piggly Wiggly grocery store in 1927 and operated as such until 1932.
- When the 21st Amendment was ratified in late 1933, there was a demand for legitimate bars to reopen. Brothers Richard and George Duke obliged, opening the Old English Tavern in the building.
- It changed hands several times until Settle purchased it in 1951. He owned it for 59 years until his death in 2010.
State of play: Though Settle is gone, his legacy lives on in his family, who still own the bar and honor Russ' "rules."
- The rules are about respect for the place and its people — don't move the furniture, question the bartenders or curse. Basically, don't be a jerk.
- It's still cash only, though there's an ATM now. There are still 45s on the jukebox.
- The bar sells six sandwiches with prices from an earlier, simpler time. A $3 grilled cheese. A $7 cheeseburger.
- There are $4 and $5 drink specials each night of the week.

The big picture: The Red Key has already solidified its place in Indianapolis history.
- Rumors that it was visited by one of the city's most famous sons, Kurt Vonnegut, are debatable, but its place in literary history isn't.
- Author Dan Wakefield's book "Going All the Way" features the bar, as does the movie adaptation starring a young Ben Affleck.
- Numerous other power players — local leaders to governors — have been Red Key regulars.
The bottom line: You never know who you'll see, but you can rest assured all will be welcome — so long as you follow the rules. 😉
