Hamilton County Democrats want to build on big gains
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Democrat Charles Hollowell speaks to a crowd of supporters after being elected the first Black sheriff in Hamilton County history. Photo: Justin L. Mack/Axios
Democrats' midterm wins have changed the conversation about the color of Hamilton County, but local party leadership says the bigger shift is that voters finally have real options.
Why it matters: For years, Hamilton County's Republican dominance left Democrats struggling to compete in local races. A more competitive ballot gives voters a reason to participate, and both parties a reason to fight for their support.
Zoom in: Meredith Fox, vice chair of the Hamilton County Democratic Party, told Axios the party isn't waiting until the next election to build on its success and is already preparing for 2027 municipal elections.
- The party's priority is filling more races with qualified candidates who are prepared to lead, rather than simply putting names on the ballot. Fox said candidates this year benefited from volunteers who supported their campaigns and worked within the party.
- She added that Democrats opened a year-round office in January 2026 and established committees in the county's four largest cities and North Hamilton County.
- They also created women's and African American caucuses to connect more residents with the party.
- "That's what's going to keep the momentum going," Fox said. "On election day, we had people already talking about thinking about 2027."
By the numbers: In WFYI's analysis of 21 contested county, state and congressional races, Democrats won 15 by an average margin of 8.8 percentage points.
- They flipped 13 seats, including the sheriff's and county clerk's offices, three of four contested County Council seats and several Statehouse races.
- They also helped oust longtime Republican officeholders, including Indiana House Speaker Todd Huston.
What they're saying: As far as Hamilton County's color these days, Fox says she believes the county is a "beautiful shade of a purple blue," arguing that voters are responding to having more Democratic choices.
- "Previously we didn't have options on the ballot, so people didn't feel like they could vote in the Democratic primary, or that it would make a difference," she said.
The other side: Republican Chair Mario Massillamany told Current Publishing last week that he expects the party to perform better in 2027, when national races won't dominate the ballot.
- He pointed to local issues such as schools, public safety, property values and community development as potential advantages.
- The GOP also retains significant local political infrastructure. Republicans held six of the 21 contested races in WFYI's analysis and remain in control of several countywide offices, including assessor, coroner, prosecutor and recorder.
- Axios Indianapolis has reached out to the Hamilton County Republican Party for additional comment.
Between the lines: University of Indianapolis political science professor Laura Merrifield Wilson told WFYI that it's too early to know whether the results represent a lasting trend or a temporary shift.
- Affordability and dissatisfaction with Republican leadership were major factors, she said.
The bottom line: Democrats have demonstrated they can compete and win in Hamilton County. The harder part is sustaining that momentum while Republicans work to reclaim their traditional advantage.
