Buying an Indy home requires $25K more income than renting
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Homebuyers in Indianapolis need to earn over $25,000 more a year than renters to afford their monthly housing payments, according to a recent Redfin report.
Why it matters: A "triple whammy" of rising home prices, high mortgage rates and a shortage of houses for sale is making it harder for renters to make the leap to homeownership, the report says.
State of sale: The household income required to afford a median home in the Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson metro has increased nearly 4% since last year. The income needed to pay the median rent has increased by 3.5% in the same time period, per Redfin.
- The median sale price for homes sold between December and February in the Indy metro was $299,675.
- The median rent for the region is $1,397.
The big picture: Nationally, homebuying costs are climbing faster than rents, which have softened due to an influx of newly built apartments.
- The median home price recently rose 4.5% from a year earlier to around $423,900, per Redfin. Mortgage rates hovered near 6.5%.
- And the median monthly rent was up 0.2% to roughly $1,600.
- The fine print: Redfin's analysis assumes a homebuyer or renter spends no more than 30% of their income on monthly payments.
Between the lines: A separate Bankrate study finds that renting is cheaper than buying a home in all 50 of the largest U.S. metro areas.
- Cost differences are widest in the West and smallest in the Rust Belt.
Zoom in: Incomes and housing costs vary widely across the metro area.
- For example, average rent in downtown Indianapolis costs $2,121 a month, per a new Zumper report.
- But when excluding downtown, monthly rent in the rest of the city averages $1,251.
- The eastside has the lowest average monthly rent at $838.
The intrigue: While the income needed to stop renting is growing, apartments are shrinking.
- Apartments built in Indy between 2015 and 2024 averaged 879 square feet — a drop of 9 square feet from the previous decade, a RentCafe analysis found.
Zoom out: Nationally, new apartments shrank decade-over-decade but grew slightly larger in recent years — averaging 908 square feet in 2024 compared to 891 in 2022, according to the report.
Yes, but: Indy renters get a little more for their money. A monthly rent of $2,000 can get you a 1,333-square-foot apartment in the Indianapolis metro.
- That's 230 square feet bigger than the national estimate of 1,103, and one of the best cost-to-rental space ratios in the U.S., according to a Redfin report.
What we're watching: The recent uptick in U.S. apartment size coincided with a building boom that has since cooled.
- President Trump's tariffs are expected to raise construction costs for new houses, another hurdle for aspiring homeowners.
Go deeper: Nearly 25% of Indy renters spend more than half their paycheck on rent