Readers say speed, not e-bikes, is the problem
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Shoshana Gordon/Axios
After our recent story on e-bike confusion, readers across Metro Detroit weighed in with concerns and observations playing out in their communities.
Why it matters: From Belle Isle's MacArthur Bridge to the Hill in Grosse Pointe Farms, e-bikes and other micromobility devices are zooming around on sidewalks, roads and trails alongside pedestrians and other users.
Reality check: A 33-year-old Ferndale resident riding an e-bike was killed on Thursday after a crash with a truck on Woodward Avenue. Ferndale police said the incident was under investigation.
What they're saying: While safety is a top priority, many readers aren't actually concerned about legal e-bikes.
- Instead, several point to high-speed riding, teen behavior and vehicles that blur the line between bicycles and motorcycles.
- Others say the real issue isn't the vehicles themselves.
"It's not that they are electric assist, it's the abuse of the speed you can attain," writes Bob Cesario, 68, a Class 2 e-bike rider in Clarkston.
Catch up quick: Michigan law addresses three classes of e-bikes, but not every electric two-wheeler is considered one.
- The law defines e-bikes as bicycles with operable pedals, a seat and a motor of 750 watts or less.
- State and local officials told us most devices causing confusion are unclassified e-bikes or e-motos that may be marketed as e-bikes and look nearly identical, but exceed Michigan's limits for motor power or speed.
The intrigue: Several readers echo a point raised by bike advocates in our story: Conflicts often arise when faster-moving riders share space with walkers and runners.
- "As both a biker and runner/walker, I believe that bikes and other wheeled devices should be separated from pedestrians whenever possible," writes Mark Tremel.
Tony Lipinski, executive director of the Recreation Authority of Roseville & Eastpointe, says e-bikes and scooters have created safety concerns on a walking path frequented by seniors.
- "We just built a new park behind our rec center," he writes. "The e-bikes and e-scooters are flying around our path creating dangerous situations."
The big picture: Speed was one theme readers repeatedly raised.
- Many think the biggest issue isn't the motor — it's how fast some riders travel through crowded spaces.
🤔 Got thoughts? Keep emailing us at [email protected].