May 22, 2024 - News

Study finds Iowa private school tuition rose by 25%

Illustration of two backpacks; one empty and one stuffed with cash.

Illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios

Iowa's new education savings account (ESA) program is influencing private schools to raise tuition rates, according to a new working paper published by Brown University.

Why it matters: The program aims to make private schools more affordable for families, but researchers warn that it could be ineffective if they raise tuition anyway.

Context: Last year, Iowa lawmakers passed a new law allowing parents to use over $7,600 annually per pupil towards private school education.

What's happening: Princeton researchers Jason Fontana and Jennifer Jennings examined Iowa private school tuition rates and compared them with neighboring Nebraska.

Context: While both states passed ESA programs in 2023, Iowa implemented them immediately for the 2023-24 school year, while Nebraska is waiting for 2024-25.

  • Fontana and Jennings also studied private school tuition rates for Iowa's pre-K students. While all K-12 students were eligible for the ESA program, preschool students were not.

The results: Across Iowa private schools, Fontana and Jennings estimated a 25% tuition rate increase when ESAs were implemented after examining rates between 2021-22 and 2023-24.

  • That's around $1,300 for kindergarten and $830 for first through 12th grades.

The intrigue: There were no noticeable increases for pre-K, Fontana tells Axios.

Zoom in: When examining kindergarten, they found a 3-5% tuition increase at private schools between 2021-22 and 2022-23 — a typical inflation amount.

  • However, when ESA was implemented in 2023-24, it jumped to a 21-24% tuition increase for kindergarten, which experienced the largest jump, Fontana says.

Between the lines: The study does not analyze if the tuition increases outpace funding provided by the ESA program, "but it is certainly a tuition increase that is above and beyond what we might anticipate in a typical year by a significant margin," Fontana says.

The other side: Tuition prices are a product of supply and demand and it's unfair to judge the program this early, says Alan Ostergren, president of The Kirkwood Institute, a conservative public interest law firm.

  • Because of the ESA program, more families are considering private school, resulting in higher demand and a "short-term" tuition rise, Ostergren says. Meanwhile, Nebraska's program has yet to start and experience the market.
  • Ostergren points to a study from The Heritage Foundation, a conservative public policy organization, that notes states with similar ESA programs delayed tuition increases over 10 years compared to states without the programs.

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Des Moines.

More Des Moines stories