Jun 2, 2021 - News
Polk County settles LGBTQ discrimination lawsuit for $200K
Illustration of a row of gavels, with all but one of them transparent.
Illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios

Polk County agreed to pay a $200K settlement Tuesday in a discrimination case alleging that a now-fired manager was recorded saying she wasn't offering a gay man a job because of his "extracurricular activities."

Why it matters: Workplace discrimination is illegal, it contributes to low morale and can cost taxpayers and businesses big bucks.

  • The case also raises more questions about whether a toxic workplace environment exists within county government now that several complaints have been filed.

What happened: James Sargent didn't get a job as a medicolegal death investigator (MDI) in 2017 despite meeting professional requirements, landing an interview and being invited to shadow another employee, according to his lawsuit.

  • An audio recording of chief MDI Amanda Luick in 2017 reportedly mocking Sargent's sexuality was discovered by another county employee in January of 2020, the suit says.
  • Soon after the recording surfaced, Luick and Polk County's longtime medical examiner Gregory Schmunk were fired.
  • The county described Schmunk's termination as a lack of oversight "related to ongoing personnel issues."

The latest: Sargent's settlement was unanimously approved with no discussion from supervisors during Monday's meeting.

  • Supervisor Matt McCoy, who's gay, told Axios that they had been briefed by the county's risk management team prior to the meeting, and that the case was clearly a civil rights violation.
  • "The hope is the county took corrective actions and this will never happen again," McCoy said.

Separately: The county's HR director Jim Nahas was fired in January for allegedly mishandling a sexual harassment claim from a female employee against McCoy.

  • McCoy denies the claim, and further accuses another supervisor, Tom Hockensmith, of using a homophobic slur to reference him during a separate incident.
  • Hockensmith denied the accusation to Axios Tuesday, calling it "despicable."

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Des Moines.

More Des Moines stories

No stories could be found

Des Moinespostcard

Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Des Moines.