Whitehall could reshape leadership with recall election
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios
The City of Whitehall faces a potential summer of change as residents consider reshaping city leadership.
Why it matters: The motivation behind the recall efforts against the mayor and two city council members appears less focused on one issue or controversy and more the result of a growing schism between residents and leaders.
State of play: In a special election Tuesday, voters will decide whether to recall Mayor Michael Bivens and Council Members Lori Elmore and Amy Harcar.
- The election was scheduled for May, but the Ohio Supreme Court ruled that Whitehall's clerk had improperly interpreted how many signatures were required.
- It was later approved again, clearing the margin required by dozens of signatures.
Friction point: Perhaps most emblematic of the local concerns: the perception in some corners that Bivens and council aren't listening.
The big picture: Recall campaigns are relatively rare in Ohio, especially in the Columbus area.
- Just two nearby have been successful in the last 15 years, according to Ballotpedia.
- Buckeye Lake voted to recall its mayor in 2024, and Johnstown recalled its council president and mayor in 2022.
- Upper Arlington voted to retain four council members in 2016.
The latest: Whitehall recall organizers were set to give a "special presentation" at a council meeting last week, but it was canceled after Ohio Auditor Keith Faber notified that it could break state laws about promoting campaign items at public meetings.
Meanwhile, Whitehall Council Member Gerald Dixon remains in office despite being accused of sexually abusing children.
- He was arrested in December, but charges were dropped two weeks later.
- Franklin County prosecutors said they'd continue investigating, and Whitehall police chief Mike Crispen has said he was "confident the decision to dismiss for future indictments is not due to a lack of evidence."
The other side: Dixon has repeatedly denied the allegations and resisted calls for him to resign.
- Voters couldn't file a recall petition until Dixon was six months into his term — or June 9.
🗳️ What's next: Polls are open for Whitehall's special election from 6:30am-7:30pm Tuesday.