Jan 24, 2022 - Food and Drink

Austin's favorite key lime pie

A photo of three pies on a plate

Coconut cream pie from Tiny Pies (bottom), Quack's key lime pie (center) and key lime pie from Lucy's Fried Chicken (top). Photo: Nicole Cobler/Axios

Reader Mitchell Carney recently laid down for Axios Austin a delectable challenge: Determine the city's best cheesecakes and key lime pies.

  • Always game, you wrote us with your favorites.

Flashback: Last week we scribbled up your favorite cheesecakes.

As your dedicated scribes, we interrupted our very own weekends to do the tough work of checking out some of your key lime pie suggestions.

Luke H. described the version at Lucy's Fried Chicken, with locations off South Congress and Burnet, as "sneaky good"

  • Nicole's opinion: Super tangy and smooth with a dollop of whipped cream. The graham cracker crust is soft and tasty but pretty thin.

Political candidate Chito Vela and journalist Elly Dearman endorsed the key lime pie at Quack's.

  • Nicole's take: Quack's is her favorite coffee spot, and the key lime pie didn't disappoint. The crust is divine, and the pie was just the right blend of tangy and sweet.

And at least a half-dozen people lauded the key lime at Bartlett's. "Yum!" was Cynthia P's succinct description.

Other readers suggested Tiny Pies.

  • Nicole says: They were sold out of key lime pies, so I snagged a yummy coconut cream pie. (Her boyfriend described it as the "perfect crust to pie ratio.")

Finally, Faith S. wrote in with this touching endorsement of Route 12 Filling Station in Dripping Springs: It "has the best key lime pie I've had in years (since my Granny passed away in 2011 actually)!"

avatar

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Austin.

🌱

Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Austin stories

No stories could be found

Austinpostcard

Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Austin.

🌱

Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more