Feb 5, 2020 - Politics & Policy

Boston Globe calls for end of first-in-the-nation tradition

Photo: Robyn Peck/Getty Images

The Boston Globe's editorial board called Wednesday for the end of the first-in-the-nation presidential votes in Iowa and New Hampshire.

The state of play: The paper is a regional powerhouse in New Hampshire and withheld its endorsement of a Democratic candidate until the state votes in its primary next week.

What they're saying:

"Sometimes, it’s more important to stand up for what’s right than what’s in one’s own interests: More important than wielding our influence on a single small state’s primary, we believe, is to call for the end of an antiquated system that gives outsized influence in choosing presidents to two states that, demographically, more resemble 19th-century America than they do the America of today."

The big picture: The board argued that the racially homogenous makeup of both Iowa and New Hampshire burdens candidates of color and instead allows candidates like Pete Buttigieg, who has struggled to attract a diverse coalition, to thrive and grab early headlines.

  • It suggested granting the first vote to a group of states more representative of the U.S. population as a whole, like Illinois, or a rotating set of varying states that could average out their demographics over time.
  • It also didn't rule out a national primary, arguing that the end of the famed retail politics of the early primary states "might be an inevitable trend in the era of social media anyway."

Worth noting: It's not the first editorial board to make a surprise decision during the 2020 Democratic primary season, as the New York Times endorsed both Elizabeth Warren and Amy Klobuchar last month.

Go deeper:

Go deeper

Trump says Iowa, New Hampshire will vote first "as long as I am President"

President Trump. Photo: Alex Wong/Getty Images

President Trump tweeted on Friday that "Iowa and New Hampshire will not be moved from the Primary Schedule as long as I am President," a decision he does not actually have direct control over.

Why it matters: Critics have argued Iowa and New Hampshire are not demographically representative of the entire nation, and some have called for a change to the primary order. February's presidential primaries and caucuses in four small states contribute 155 pledged delegates of the 3,979 Democratic total, giving early voting states "an outsized role in the narratives that can determine the eventual nominee," the Washington Post notes.

Voter turnout breaks New Hampshire Democratic primary record

Sen. Bernie Sanders rallies in New Hampshire on Feb. 11. Photo: Jessica Rinaldi/The Boston Globe via Getty Images

New Hampshire voters broke the state's 2008 record this week for the most votes cast in a New Hampshire Democratic primary election, the party announced Wednesday.

By the numbers: More than 300,000 Democratic votes were cast on Tuesday — easily breaking 2008's record of 288,000 votes — while roughy 156,000 Republican votes were cast, per New Hampshire's secretary of state.

Iowa debacle haunts 2020 Democrats

Pete Buttigieg in New Hampshire yesterday. Photo: Spencer Platt/Getty Images

Pete Buttigieg sees a moment to overtake Joe Biden with an electability message after the scrambled Iowa results left some top Biden supporters distraught.

If the partial results released yesterday by the Iowa Democratic Party had been trumpeted Monday night instead of being delayed by the app snafu, Buttigieg would have been a national sensation.