Schumer's danger signs
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
The warning signs are flashing for Democratic candidates in three of Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer's most important states for playing defense.
Why it matters: The Rust Belt toss-ups of Michigan, Ohio and — as of today — Wisconsin could make the difference between a tiny GOP Senate majority next year or their biggest advantage since 2016.
- Schumer has strong incumbents in Wisconsin and Ohio. Both benefited from last running in 2018 when Donald Trump's name was off the ballot, but his presidency drove Democratic turnout.
- One of Schumer's earlier toss-ups — Montana — is trending the wrong way. Cook moved it last month to "lean Republican."
🦡 1) Wisconsin: We told you last week that Sen. Tammy Baldwin's (D) re-election fight was setting off alarms among Wisconsin Dems.
- Today, Cook tightened her race against wealthy GOP businessman Eric Hovde from "lean Dem" to "toss-up." Baldwin cleaned house in 2018, winning by 10 percentage points.
🔥 2) Ohio: Democratic incumbent Sherrod Brown is a red state survivor, but his once-sizable lead over Bernie Moreno has been shrinking.
- NRSC internal polling showed them deadlocked at 46%, the Hill reported today. Back in 2018, Brown won by seven percentage points.
⏰ 3) Michigan: Democratic nominee Rep. Elissa Slotkin has sounded the alarm as polling shows former Rep. Mike Rogers (R) closing in.
- Super PAC cash is flying into Michigan, as we reported. That includes $22.5 million from the GOP leader Mitch McConnell-aligned Senate Leadership Fund.
Zoom out: The good news largely stops there for Republicans, who came into the cycle with a historically favorable Senate map. The map's much better for Schumer's Democrats in 2026.
- The GOP has begun to triage: The NRSC has less than $1 million in ad reservations between both Arizona and Nevada — once considered pickup opportunities — from now until Election Day.
The other side: Democrats are relying on good news in long-shot races, including ratings changes in their favor in Texas and Nebraska.
- NRSC Communications Director Mike Berg said the party has seen "positive movement across the board" after being "outspent badly over the summer."
- DSCC Communications Director David Bergstein said that the GOP's "flawed candidates are hurting their prospects across the entire Senate map — and while the NRSC is slashing their advertising the DSCC is going on offense."
— Stef Kight and Stephen Neukam
