Trump makes a dramatic return to Pennsylvania shooting scene
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Former President Donald Trump speaks behind bulletproof glass at his rally in Butler, Pa., on Saturday. Photo: Doug Mills/The New York Times
BUTLER, Pa. — Eighty-four days after former President Trump's rally speech here was cut short after just six minutes when he was shot in the ear, Trump returned Saturday for a make-up rally that was part commemoration, part celebration — and the usual attacks on Democrats.
Driving the news: In the same field where he was shot, Trump led a dramatic rally that featured prayer, opera, parachute divers, and an artist who did a live painting of Corey Comperatore, the Trump supporter who was killed in the shocking attack on July 13.
- Security was extraordinarily tight, a response to the failures that set the stage for the July shooting.
- The Secret Service and other law enforcement agencies employed a web of measures that were visible at every turn — from tethered surveillance drones to officers on horseback, dogs, and dozens more armed security officers.
- Yellow and white shipping containers surrounded portions of the venue to block off lines of sight.
- Bulletproof glass surrounded Trump as he spoke. It's been a fixture of his outdoor rallies since the shooting.
What we're watching: "We love Pennsylvania, and as I was saying .... ," Trump began, initially striking a rather unifying tone before descending into his more familiar partisan speech.
- At 6:11 pm, the moment when the shots began on July 13, Trump held a moment of silence, followed by bells tolling and an opera singer performing "Ave Maria."
- He praised Comperatore, the former fire chief who was killed during the assassination attempt, and recognized Comperatore's wife and children, who were in the audience.
- Trump talked for 26 minutes without mentioning his election opponent, Vice President Kamala Harris. But then he began attacking Harris on issues ranging from fracking to immigration and how the Biden administration is handling the response to Hurricane Helene.
Zoom in: The scene at grounds of the Butler Farm Show was a far cry from the disturbing images of the shooting's aftermath, when chairs were strewn everywhere by rally-goers escaping the scene, bomb squads were looking for signs of a larger attack, and yellow tape blocked off a bloodied stage.
- On Saturday the food stands were back, and the smell of corndogs and bratwurst was in the air. A robust crowd filled the venue, as did music booming from two large speaker columns.
- An American flew flag high above the stage, propped up by two cranes, just as it had in July. Groups of Trump supporters periodically erupted in chants of "Fight! Fight! Fight!" — Trump's impromptu rallying cry after he was shot.
What they're saying: "He needs a pope-mobile," Susie Ceraso, a 72-year-old retired landscaper and contractor helper from Pittsburgh, said of the recent threats to Trump's life.
- "I'm really afraid if he lives until he is elected, that he's not going to make through his second term."
- Ceraso had returned to Butler alone, after attending the July rally with a friend. She recalls spotting herself and her American flag-themed cowboy hat in the close up videos of the shooting and the aftermath.
Between the lines: Trump's running mate, Ohio Sen. JD Vance, spoke an hour before the ex-president and had a pointed message for Democrats.
- "After the heartache of that day, we hope our opponents remember that before we are Democrats or before we are Republicans, we are Americans," Vance said.
- "Our opponents have not heeded Abraham Lincoln's words...they continue to use dangerous inflammatory rhetoric."
Such comments blaming Democrats have been common among Republicans since Trump was attacked.
- Democrats have been quick to point out that much of Trump's campaign is rooted in his personal grievances and on his divisive attacks on Democrats.
- While Democrats have cast Trump as a threat to democracy, Trump repeatedly has told his followers that "you're not going to have a country anymore" if he's not elected next month.
The intrigue: The rally also featured two other speakers who are highly involved behind the scenes for Trump, but who hadn't previously appeared on stage at his events.
- Tech billionaire Elon Musk, whose America PAC has been running Trump's outside ground operation, echoed some of Trump's rhetoric when he ominously predicted that "this will be the last election" unless Trump wins.
- Scott Presler, a GOP activist leading the voter registration group Early Vote Action, appealed to union workers, Amish communities, hunters, and schoolteachers to "use your ballot."
