Retailers are having a foot traffic problem
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Just as department stores were aiming to get back on their feet this holiday season, shoppers walked in the other direction.
Driving the news: Net sales rose in 2021 compared to pre-pandemic levels, but department store chains can't yet claim full recovery: Foot traffic has fallen sharply.
Why it matters: Investors are paying more attention to foot traffic, especially because a number of department stores are splitting off the e-commerce businesses that are now fetching higher valuations.
- "The holy grail in retail investing is the retailer with positive [foot] traffic," Ryan Cotton, Bain Capital's global head of consumer and retail, tells Axios.
By the numbers: Traffic for all apparel stores is down 5% for the year (as of Dec. 6) compared to 2019, according to data provided to Axios by Placer.ai.
- In the month of November, apparel suffered a 9.4% decline in foot traffic versus November 2019.
- Traffic at Macy's and Kohl's, both of which are being targeted by activist investors, was down 19.1% and 12.6%, respectively, from January through November.
- JCPenney and Belk saw foot traffic at their chains drop by 28.1% and 21.9%, respectively, over the same period.
On the flip side: Saks Fifth Avenue saw traffic actually grow 6.2% in 2021 from 2019.
State of play: November marked a significant setback in retailers' push to bring more people in the door. Much of this was due to the receding role of Black Friday in shoppers' lives — and retailers like Walmart opting to close on Thanksgiving Day, Ethan Chernofsky, VP of marketing at Placer.ai, tells Axios.
The big picture: Declining foot traffic is the persistent retail trend, Cotton says.
- "The traditional mall stands as one of the starkest examples of this phenomenon — the place we all couldn’t wait to go in our teens is now the place we all work to avoid," he adds.
The bottom line: With price increases skewing year-over-year sales comparisons, foot traffic may become a better barometer for measuring retailers' health and determining valuations.
Go deeper: Our insatiable appetite for speedy delivery
