Axios Pro Rata

May 14, 2024
Top of the Morning
Illustration: Annelise Capossela/Axios
Private equity is breathing easier this morning, after a federal judge in Texas dismissed what could have been a landmark antitrust lawsuit against Welsh Carson Anderson & Stowe.
Catch up quick: The Federal Trade Commission last year sued both WCAS and one of its portfolio companies for suppressing competition and driving up prices of anesthesiology services in Texas.
- WCAS in 2012 had formed U.S. Anesthesia Partners (USAP), a platform to acquire anesthesia services groups.
- The FTC claimed that WCAS and USAP bought up "nearly every large anesthesia practice in Texas," in order to form a dominant provider, and then forged price-setting agreements with providers that had remained independent.
- WCAS currently holds just a 23% stake in USAP, but the FTC argued that the private equity firm remained in effective control of an ongoing antitrust violation.
Why it matters: This was the FTC's first direct swing at private equity, and an effort to shove a dagger through the corporate veil.
- Had it succeeded, private equity firms could have feared liability for the actions of portfolio companies. Moreover, it could have been a death knell for the industry's popular roll-up strategies.
The latest: Judge Kenneth Hoyt dismissed WCAS as a defendant, although allowed the case to proceed against USAP.
- Hoyt reasoned that the FTC didn't "cite any authority for the proposition that receiving profits from an entity that may be violating antitrust laws is itself a violation of antitrust laws."
- He added that the FTC didn't meet its burden in proving that WCAS continues to be in control of USAP, given its minority equity stake a minority representation on the USAP board, no matter how "hands-on" WCAS may be. That does seem to provide FTC with some wiggle room if it brings a future case against a control investor, but not here.
- Finally, Hoyt determined that the FTC's more appropriate antitrust attack against WCAS was on its initial acquisition of an anesthesiology practice in Texas, rather than in the subsequent purchases that were technically done by USAP. Again, a lesson for future FTC litigation.
What WCAS is saying: "We are gratified that the court dismissed the FTC's case against Welsh Carson in its entirety. As we have said from the beginning, this case was without factual or legal basis."
The bottom line: The FTC took a big swing against private equity. And missed.
The BFD: Meta edition
Today's event kicks off at 2pm PT in San Francisco. Hundreds of you are joining us in person, and everyone can join via livestream.
Here's our lineup, and why each one of them is a BFD:
Steve Young (2pm PT)
- He's got Super Bowl rings, a Hall of Fame jacket, and private equity bona fides as co-founder and chairman of HGGC. Our talk comes just as the NFL considers allowing PE firms to buy into franchises for the first time.
Karen DeSalvo (2:30pm PT)
- She's the chief health officer of Google, which is at the epicenter of applying AI to health care. Or, put another way, the future of health care.
Aravind Srinivas (2:50pm PT)
- He's the founder and CEO of Perplexity, an AI search "unicorn" that's seeking to move LLM applications past chatbots.
Jim Lanzone (3:40pm PT)
- He's the CEO of Yahoo, brought in by Apollo to turn the company around after it was acquired in 2021. He's previously led such companies as CBS (yeah, the network owned by Paramount) and Tinder.
Kathryn Haun (4pm PT)
- She's the former federal prosecutor who's become one of crypto's top venture capitalists, leading an eponymous firm that raised $1.5 billion for its debut funds. Haun also recently announced plans to leave the board of Coinbase, after a seven-year run.
David Sacks (4:20pm PT)
- The PayPal Mafia member has been a successful founder (Yammer), CEO (Zenefits), and venture capitalist (Craft Ventures), and today launched a new AI startup called Glue that's seeking to be the next big platform for workplace communications. He's also co-host of the popular "All-in Podcast," and is known for diving into some of America's most contentious political debates.
Venture Capital Deals
• Bot Co., a robotics startup led by Kyle Vogt (co-founder of Cruise and Twitch), raised $150m from Nat Friedman, Daniel Gross, Spark Capital, Quiet Capital, and Patrick and John Collison. axios.link/44EbJub
• CRMBonus, a Brazilian marketing automation platform for retailers, raised $75m in Series B funding. Bond led, and was joined by Valor Capital. crmbonus.com.br
⚽ Kings League, a Spanish soccer competition, raised €60m led by Left Lane Capital. www.kingsleague.pro
🚑 Chapter, a Medicare navigation platform, raised $50m in Series C funding, per Axios Pro. XYZ Venture Capital led, and was joined by insiders Addition, Narya Capital, Susa Ventures, and Maverick Ventures. axios.link/3V0GYMw
• Aplazo, a Mexican BNPL startup, raised $45m in Series B funding. QED Investors led, and was joined by Oak HC/FT, Kaszek, and Picus Capital. axios.link/3QKRrcB
• Fintech Farm, a London neobank-in-a-box startup, raised $32m in Series B funding co-led by Nordstar and Bank of Georgia. axios.link/3ypAGgB
• Sona, a London-based frontline workforce management platform, raised $27.5m in Series A funding. Felicis led, and was joined by Gradient Ventures, Antler, SpeedInvest, Northzone, and Bag Ventures. axios.link/3UCwqSF
• Sesame, a Spanish HR software startup, raised €23m from GP Bullhound and insider PSG. axios.link/3JUjaUu
• Infinite Orbits, a French in-orbit services startup, raised €12m from Newfund Capital and EIC Fund. axios.link/4dSLftd
• Arch Labs, a Bitcoin-native application platform, raised $7m in seed funding. Multicoin Capital led, and was joined by Portal Ventures, OKX Ventures, Big Brain Holdings, CMS Holdings, and Tangent. axios.link/3K01uqC
• Monitaur, a Boston provider of model governance software for highly regulated industries, raised $6m in Series A funding. Cultivation Capital led, axios.link/4beRFkl
• Arcium, a Swiss on-chain confidential computing project, raised $5.5m led by Greenfield Capital. axios.link/3yikuxV
• AgriDex, a British platform for tokenizing agricultural commodities, raised $5m. Endeavour Ventures led, and was joined by African Crops Limited, Oldenburg Vineyards, and Hank Oberoi. axios.link/3UXEzm7
• Zest, a bitcoin lending protocol, raised $3.5m in seed funding led by Draper Associates. zestprotocol.com
• Magic Lane, a Dutch mapping and location platform, raised €3m led by No Such Ventures. axios.link/3K2yoa8
Private Equity Deals
• GAI Consultants, a portfolio company of Comvest Partners, acquired Creighton Manning, an Albany, N.Y., engineering and environmental consulting firm. gaiconsultants.com
• KKR agreed to buy IQGeo Group (LSE: IQG), a British geospatial software provider, for £316m. axios.link/3QHXcHS
• NexCore, a commercial HVAC platform owned by Trinity Hunt Partners, acquired Sylvester & Cockrum, a commercial HVAC firm focused on the Southeastern U.S. nxcus.com
• TDR Capital is in exclusive talks to buy Italian discount retailer Acqua & Sapone from H.I.G. Capital, beating out rival bids from CVC Capital Partners and Clayton Dubilier & Rice, per Bloomberg. axios.link/3wGuiBa
• Warburg Pincus will pay around $555m to buy the affordable housing finance arm of India's Shriram Finance. axios.link/3UWWfy8
Public Offerings
• Aeromexico filed for a U.S. IPO, two years after the airline delisted in Mexico. It plans to list on the NYSE (AERO) and reports a $428m net loss on $4.9b in revenue for 2023. axios.link/3UG24P1
• Novelis, an Atlanta-based maker of aluminum products, filed for an IPO that Renaissance Capital estimates could raise $1.3b. It plans to list on the NYSE (NVL) and reports $600m of net income on $16.2b in revenue for the year ending March 31, 2024. axios.link/3wyY9LX
Liquidity Events
• Cinven is seeking to sell Jaggaer, a Morrisville, N.C., supply chain software firm that could fetch around $3b (including debt), per Reuters. axios.link/3V0QYEH
• TabaPay, a SoftBank portfolio company, abandoned plans to buy banking-as-a-service provider Synapse out of bankruptcy. Synapse had raised over $50m from firms like a16z, Trinity Ventures, and Core Innovation Capital. axios.link/3QGvJqj
More M&A
• Anglo American (LSE: AAL) launched a major restructuring, as it seeks to fend off a $43b takeover bid from Australian miner BHP Group (ASX: BHP). It would include the sale or spinout of Anglo American's coal, nickel, diamond and platinum businesses. axios.link/4beDonV
• Kraft Heinz (Nasdaq: KHC) is exploring a sale of its Oscar Meyer meats unit, which could fetch between $3b to $5b, per the WSJ. axios.link/4bCN6Ao
⚡ Italgas (Milan: IG) said it's in talks to buy smaller Italian gas distributor 2i Rete Gas. axios.link/3WGrK0D
⚡ Institutional Shareholder Services recommended that Hess (NYSE: HES) shareholders abstain from voting on the $53b takeover by Chevron (NYSE: CVX), one day after Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said the FTC should "pump the brakes" on the deal.
• Uber (NYSE: UBER) agreed to buy the Taiwan unit of Foodpanda, a subsidiary of Delivery Hero, for $950m in cash. axios.link/3K0Pk0x
• Verizon (NYSE: VZ) wants to buy back a stake in its Los Angeles business from US Cellular (NYSE: USM). axios.link/3UXxz8F
🚑 Walgreens Boots Alliance (Nasdaq: WBA) is again seeking to sell Boots, its British pharmacy chain that could fetch nearly $9b, per Bloomberg. axios.link/3wvK6Xz
Fundraising
• Accel raised $650m for its eighth Europe-focused VC fund. axios.link/3WBdy9d
• Blisce, a Paris-based VC firm, is raising up to €150m for a climate-focused fund. It also hired Lucie Basch, co-founder of Too Good To Go, as a venture partner. axios.link/3JYEet5
• ChrysCapital, an Indian PE firm, this year will seek to raise around $2b for its 10th fund, per PE International. axios.link/4bt4K9A
🌎 Cresta Fund Management of Dallas is raising $650m for a fund targeting alternative fuels, carbon capture and similar "green molecules" sectors, per Axios Pro. axios.link/4ajMluM
• FSN Capital, a Swedish PE firm focused on "purpose-driven companies," raised €400m for a small-cap fund. axios.link/4bD8UMg
• Norrsken VC, a Swedish VC firm focused on impact investing, raised €320m for its second fund. axios.link/3yjLFZ5
• Pitchdrive, a Belgian VC firm, raised €40m for its third fund. axios.link/4adAM8B
🚑 Sands Capital raised $555m for its third life sciences fund. sandscapital.com
It's Personnel
• Terri Burns, a former GV Ventures partner, has launched an early-stage VC firm called Type Capital. axios.link/44CDof3
• Matt Le Noury joined Gen II as head of European client operations. He previously was with Crestbridge. axios.link/3WGVI4t
• Norwest promoted Lauren Beauchamp to VP of growth equity. axios.link/4bnNGCo
• T. Rowe Price named Doug Keller as global head of alternatives. axios.link/3qwJ2iP
• Migo Terjanian joined BayPine as a partner and head of IR. He previously was with BC Partners. axios.link/3UGoLmb
Final Numbers


Meme stocks are back!
- Okay, they never really left (e.g., Trump Media), so this is more like a return of the kings.
Driving the news: Keith "Roaring Kitty" Gill yesterday posted on Twitter for the first time in nearly three years. He didn't mention any specific companies, but just his very presence caused GameStop and AMC shares to skyrocket.
Thought bubble, from Axios' Felix Salmon: "This isn't a fully-fledged frenzy — yet. GameStop and AMC are well off the 2021 highs of $120.75 and $640.76, respectively.
- "Plus, short interest in both stocks is much lower than it was in 2021, making it more difficult to cause short squeezes like the ones that helped drive the stocks 'to the moon.'"
Thanks for reading Axios Pro Rata, and to copy editor Bryan McBournie! Please ask your friends, colleagues, and defense attorneys to sign up.
Sign up for Axios Pro Rata

Dan Primack’s briefing on VC, PE & M&A for dealmakers.

