Axios Login

November 28, 2022
I hope you aren't too full from Thanksgiving to read today's Login.
š¦ Situational awareness: Twitter is facing a flood of adult content spam in China meant to drown out news about widespread protests, the Washington Post reports.
Today's newsletter 1,250 words, a 5-minute read.
1 big thing: Musk's Twitter amnesty raises fears over online hate
Illustration: Shoshana Gordon/Axios
Elon Musk is promising to reinstate more banned Twitter accounts, even as a coalition of groups is out with a fresh warning that online hate is on the rise, Axios' Ashley Gold and I report.
Why it matters: It's another risky bet by Twitter's "free speech"-espousing owner that he can dial back enforcement of content rules without releasing a torrent of racism, anti-semitism and anti-LGBTQ speech that could further erode the service's already shaky advertising base.
Driving the news: Elon Musk said in a tweet on Thursday that he would offer "amnesty" starting this week to previously banned accounts, provided they hadn't broken the law or engaged in "egregious" spam.
- The move followed an unscientific poll of his Twitter followers showing support for such a move.
- After a similar poll, Musk earlier reinstated the accounts of former president Donald Trump, who was permanently suspended from Twitter after his tweets helped incite the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol, as well as several other banned accounts.
- At the same time, a wave of layoffs and resignations of Twitter staff and contractors have decimated the teams responsible for monitoring and taking action against rule-breaking accounts.
Meanwhile, civil rights groups say that women, people of color and LGBTQ folks are experiencing both harassment and threats of real-world violence when they go online, according to findings of a new poll the groups commissioned from YouGov and shared first with Axios.
By the numbers: In results of the poll, conducted on behalf of Ultraviolet, GLAAD, Kairos, and the Women's March, 57% of respondents said they have seen a post that calls for actual violence against someone based on their race, gender, sexuality, or another personal characteristic.
- Women and people who identify as LGBTQ+ reported higher rates of harassment than the average respondent.
- Respondents described false information as an issue across multiple platforms, with Facebook and Twitter being seen as the most problematic, and a large majority said the platforms should be held accountable.
The big picture: Civil rights groups have already pointed to a rise in racist and antisemitic tweets under Elon Musk, even ahead of moves to reinstate previously banned accounts.
- Advocates have been sounding alarms about growing risks of online hate speech translating into real-world violence, with renewed warnings after this month's shooting in Colorado Springs.
Between the lines: Musk's amnesty declaration suggests that Twitter's old speech rules no longer apply, and henceforth only law-breaking, "egregious spam" and calls to violence will cause Twitter to take action.
- That appears to leave the door wide open for hate speech, abuse, bullying and targeted harassment.
- Musk followed up his pledge to reinstate previously banned accounts with a call for civil debate on the site, but offered no plan for how to encourage it.
- Musk said in a Twitter conversation with author Stephen King on Saturday that his goal is "a trusted digital town square, where a wide range of views are tolerated, provided people donāt break the law or spam." He also promised that "any incitement to violence will result in account suspension."
Yes, but: Critics of Muskās approach say that he is asking for civil debates where the starting point is inherently un-civil, as when people express white supremacy or equate LGBTQ identity with child abuse.
- "I cannot 'engage in civil debate' about whether or not I am who I say I am or whether I should exist, but ok, dude," transgender writer Parker Molloy said in response to Musk.
Be smart: Musk's toleration of a broader range of hateful speech might pass legal muster in the U.S. but is likely to run afoul of laws in many nations around the world.
The bottom line: Maintaining civil discourse online has always been a challenge, and enforcing speech rules is tough even when they're consistent and well understood. Musk's improvisational policy-by-tweet almost guarantees Twitter's speech conflicts will deepen.
2. Rights, LGBTQ+ groups oppose kids' online bill
Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios
Dozens of human rights and LGBTQ+ organizations wrote to members of Congress Monday opposing a kids' online safety bill they argue would not actually help make the internet a better place for children and teens, Axios' Ashley Gold reports.
Driving the news: The letter comes as Senate sponsors of the Kids Online Safety Act push for its passage in the lame duck session of Congress, calling it an important way to hold social media platforms accountable for harm to children in the absence of a broader U.S. online privacy law.
What they're saying: "[We believe] that the privacy, online safety, and digital well-being of children should be protected," groups including the ACLU, GLAAD, Fight for the Future, Electronic Frontier Foundation, Public Knowledge, American Library Association and Wikimedia Foundation write in the letter to senators.
- "However, [the bill] would undermine those goals... by effectively forcing providers to use invasive filtering and monitoring tools; jeopardizing private, secure communications; incentivizing increased data collection on children and adults; and undermining the delivery of critical services to minors by public agencies like schools," the groups write.
How it works: The groups say the bill's requirement that sites filter online content would lead to "over-moderation" and cut off members of marginalized younger groups who rely on online services to learn about sex education or access LGBTQ+ resources.
- They also argue the bill's parental supervision aspect "would effectively require online services to enable parental surveillance of 15- and 16-year-olds by default" and could harm teens experiencing domestic violence.
- They warn the bill could lead to sites inadvertently collecting more information from younger users than necessary because of age verification requirements.
3. FCC bans U.S. sales of Huawei and ZTE devices
Illustration: Rebecca Zisser/Axios
The Federal Communications Commission on Friday announced new rules banning U.S. sales and imports of new Huawei and ZTE telecommunications devices out of national security concerns, Axios' Natalie Daher and Hope King report.
Why it matters: The ban is the latest escalation in U.S. policy toward Chinese telecom equipment makers, which began during the Obama administration and accelerated during the Trump administration.
- Other companies affected by the action include Hytera Communications, Hangzhou Hikvision Digital Technology and Dahua Technology.
Driving the news: "Today, the FCC takes an unprecedented step to safeguard our networks and strengthen Americaās national security," Brendan Carr, the FCC's commissioner, tweeted on Friday.
- "Our unanimous decision represents the first time in FCC history that we have voted to prohibit the authorization of new equipment based on national security concerns," he added.
The big picture: Huawei and ZTE are two of the world's biggest suppliers of telecom equipment.
- Countries including Canada, Britain and AustraliaĀ have ramped up restrictions against the use of 5G technologies from Huawei and ZTE in recent years.
- Huawei executives have previously said the company does not give data to the Chinese government and that its equipment is not compromised.
4. Take note
On Tap
- Amazon's AWS re:Invent conference takes place all week in Las Vegas.
(Not-yet) Trading Places
- Sinead McSweeney, a Twitter public policy VP who did not accept Elon Musk's "hardcore" ultimatum, has gotten an Irish court to issue an injunction preventing her termination. (Irish Times)
ICYMI
- A Minecraft bot from OpenAI has learned to perform a wide range of complex tasks within the game. (MIT Technology Review)
- The South China Morning Post has an in-depth look at the protests and conditions within Foxconn's "iPhone City" in locked-down Zhengzhou.
- Anti-COVID restriction protests at Appleās main iPhone plant in Zhengzhou could result in a production shortfall of up to 6 million iPhone Pro units this year. (Bloomberg)
- A U.K.-based startup is making video games for dogs to help aging canine brains. (Axios)
5. After you Login
Check out the concentration on this baby bass drummer.
Thanks to Scott Rosenberg and Peter Allen Clark for editing and Nick Aspinwall for copy editing this newsletter.
Sign up for Axios Login

Taking you inside the AI revolution, and delivering scoops and insights on the technologies reshaping our lives.


