Suspects charged in Lurie security incident
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Mayor Daniel Lurie. Photo: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
San Francisco's district attorney on Monday charged two men in connection with a street confrontation that left a member of Mayor Daniel Lurie's security detail injured.
Why it matters: The incident has sparked controversy in recent days after a video posted to social media appeared to show the bodyguard initiated contact — countering early descriptions of the encounter.
- The scuffle, which unfolded in the Tenderloin, is raising questions about police use of force and the mayor's hands-on approach to addressing San Francisco's homelessness crisis, the San Francisco Standard reports.
Catch up quick: Last Thursday evening, Lurie's SUV was blocked by three people on Cedar Street near Polk, per Mission Local.
- Lurie got out and asked them to move. When one person didn't, a member of his security team stepped in and a physical altercation followed.
- The officer later hit his head on the pavement and suffered non-life-threatening injuries. Lurie, who was unharmed, observed the struggle as he walked by. He later told reporters he went to look for assistance as the confrontation intensified.
Driving the news: The two men who were subsequently arrested — Abraham Simon, 33, and Tony Phillips, 44, who was previously arrested in 2019 — will be arraigned on Tuesday, District Attorney Brooke Jenkins said.
- Simon was charged with resisting or obstructing an officer. Phillips faces additional counts including assault on a police officer causing great bodily injury and resisting an executive officer.
Between the lines: Surveillance footage posted to social media first reported on by the San Francisco Chronicle depicted the officer forcefully shoving Phillips to the ground before the fight escalated.
- The video complicates initial accounts of the encounter and raises questions about who initiated force.
- Lurie said last week he stopped and got out of the vehicle because he was concerned about pedestrian and traffic safety, adding that he was "really happy" the members of his security detail were "OK."
The city's Department of Police Accountability has also launched a probe into what happened, per the San Francisco Chronicle.
The big picture: The episode highlights the tension between Lurie's street-level approach to homelessness and the volatile conditions in neighborhoods like the Tenderloin, where open-air drug use remains pervasive.
- It also blunts his public safety messaging that San Francisco is on the upswing, while resurfacing broader questions about policing tactics — especially use of force on the unhoused.
- Lurie's office did not respond to Axios' questions Monday about his reaction to the footage or whether he plans to adjust his street-level engagement strategy. He issued a statement saying that he hopes "these individuals will be held accountable," in response to Jenkins' decision to charge the men in addition to another suspect in the unprovoked stabbing of a man in Chinatown last week.
- The San Francisco Police Officers Association praised the security detail's actions in what it called a "dangerous and unpredictable situation," per Mission Local. Meanwhile, critics have argued the video warrants closer review of the officer's conduct.
Randy Shaw, the executive director of the nonprofit the Tenderloin Housing Clinic, told Axios the incident reflects long-standing concerns about the Tenderloin's street conditions.
- He sees the confrontation as emblematic of the daily challenges residents in the neighborhood face, who are often worried about their own safety.
- "If this incident occurred in the Marina District, people would say, 'What the hell? How could that happen?'... But it occurs here, and they say, 'Well, those are the kind of people who are allowed to be in the Tenderloin,'" he said. "We shouldn't still be having these problems in this neighborhood."