Aug 31, 2017

Expert doubles down: robots still threaten 47% of U.S. jobs

John Minchillo / AP

A leading authority on robotization has doubled down on his most controversial forecast — that automation threatens 47% of American jobs. And he belittles critics who say technological upheaval seems scary but always generates sufficient new work.

Why it matters: In a new report by Citi, Carl Frey, a professor at Oxford University, also forecasts the demise of American retail work. If he is right, it is an outcome that will reach further than the decimation of manufacturing because it will involve a different, large set of cities.

Frey writes in the Citi report:

  • Retail work is likely to vanish in the coming decades, leading to a long, unknowable period of adjustment before retail workers find new employment.
  • "Groups that have lost out to automation since the computer revolution are still struggling to find new and better-paid jobs," and retail workers will find it just as hard "to find solid footing in the labor market."

More than anyone, Frey and artificial intelligence expert Michael Osborne ignited the current fear of a robot apocalypse with a joint 2013 paper that introduced their famous 47% forecast. Critics have attacked the core of their work. The most frequent pitch I receive is from PR agents offering yet another expert rejecting robot-induced mass unemployment. Their scorn has two main assertions:

  • The theory of "technological unemployment," conceived by John Maynard Keynes in the 1930s, has been proven wrong. Keynes said tech was advancing so fast that the economy would fail to replace jobs that were destroyed. But, just as they have been through repeated technological disruptions since the start of the Industrial Age in the early 19th century, Keynes' fears of mass joblessness were not borne out.
  • The robot age will turn out the same — normal economic churn will replace destroyed jobs with mostly unforeseeable new ones.

In the Citi report, Frey quotes his critics and rejects their arguments. He writes:

  • Keynes was not wrong about the destruction of jobs, which happened, but about the number of jobs that would arise to replace them.
  • This time, the scale on which jobs will be replaced — whether this technological upheaval will turn out the same as the past — is ultimately unknowable at this stage.
  • "What we do know is that the potential scope of automation has expanded rapidly and that many of today's jobs will change or disappear."
  • And the robust spread of automation suggests that "historical rates of productivity growth are likely to be a poor guide to the future."

Other highlights:

  • Despite appearances, brick-and-mortar still accounts for the overwhelming percentage of sales — 92%, according to Citi. But e-commerce is up from a 2% share a decade ago, and the number is rising by 20% a year. The cost of automation is falling, making retailers more willing to use it to lay off more costly workers.80% of the jobs in transportation, warehousing and logistics are vulnerable to automation.63% of sales jobs are vulnerable.The average number of robots in fulfillment centers like Amazon warehouses was 461 in 2013. But now it is 3,200."The disruption is very much at its infancy," Martin Wilkie, the lead author of the report, tells Axios. He said that, in the coming decades, "the premise is that stores are bypassed in their entirety."
  • E-commerce's reach is patchy across the globe:In big U.S. and European cities, it's possible to order and receive a product in one or two hours. In Brazil, the average promised delivery time is 9 days.South Koreans do 10% of their grocery purchases on-line, along with 7.2% in Japan and 5.3% in France. The U.S. is among the lowest, with only 1.4%.

Go deeper

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 3 p.m. ET: 5,931,112 — Total deaths: 357,929 — Total recoveries — 2,388,172Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 3 p.m. ET: 1,711,313 — Total deaths: 101,129 — Total recoveries: 391,508 — Total tested: 15,192,481Map.
  3. States: New York to allow private businesses to deny entry to customers without masks.
  4. Public health: Louisiana Sen. Cassidy wants more frequent testing of nursing home workers.
  5. Congress: Pelosi slams McConnell on stimulus delay — Sen. Tim Kaine and wife test positive for coronavirus antibodies.
  6. Tech: Twitter fact-checks Chinese official's claims that coronavirus originated in U.S.
  7. What should I do? When you can be around others after contracting the coronavirus — Traveling, asthma, dishes, disinfectants and being contagiousMasks, lending books and self-isolatingExercise, laundry, what counts as soap — Pets, moving and personal healthAnswers about the virus from Axios expertsWhat to know about social distancingHow to minimize your risk.
  8. Other resources: CDC on how to avoid the virus, what to do if you get it, the right mask to wear.

Subscribe to Mike Allen's Axios AM to follow our coronavirus coverage each morning from your inbox.

Updated 26 mins ago - Politics & Policy

Twitter fact-checks Chinese official's claims that coronavirus originated in U.S.

Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Zhao Lijian. Photo: Greg Baker/AFP via Getty Images

Twitter slapped a fact-check label on a pair of months-old tweets from a Chinese government spokesperson that falsely suggested that the coronavirus originated in the U.S. and was brought to Wuhan by the U.S. military, directing users to "get the facts about COVID-19."

Why it matters: The labels were added after criticism that Twitter had fact-checked tweets from President Trump about mail-in voting, but not other false claims from Chinese Communist Party officials and other U.S. adversaries.

Podcast: Trump vs. Twitter, round two

President Trump is escalating his response to Twitter’s fact check of his recent tweets about mail-in voting, issuing an executive order that's designed to begin limiting social media's liability protections. Dan digs in with Axios' Margaret Harding McGill.

Go deeper: Twitter vs. Trump... vs. Twitter

2 hours ago - Politics & Policy