Lazaro Gamio / Axios

Snapchat stories by companies have great engagement stats but the rules Snapchat places on stories mean advertisements must run separately, where the effectiveness is less clear.

Why this matters: Snapchat's parent Snap is preparing to go public with a valuation of more than $16 billion because more than 150 million people use the app every day and investors think that will turn into a gusher of money from advertising. But if advertisers don't feel like the platform is delivering, Snapchat could end up an investor disappointment like Twitter, instead of a home run like Facebook.

A study by Snaplytics finds that Snapchat stories (not ads) have an open rate of 50% and that 88% of people that start watching a story watch it all the way through — up to 11 snaps on average. Those are tremendous engagement stats. But companies can't use those kinds of stories to sell. Snapchat makes companies buy ads if they're going to explicitly push products or market content.

So the question is, are Snap ads effective? We don't exactly know.

  • Maybe yes. Snapchat is private about releasing statistics around their ad campaigns, but ahead of its IPO, they shared a few case studies in its S-1 filing that show the effectiveness of brands using Snap Ads. Han Ma, Associate Director at Ketchum Digital, who works for an array of companies on Snapchat, says overall, companies can leverage more refined targeting methods by buying ads. "Stronger analytics lead to stronger insights, which lead to better opportunities to optimize content and strategies for brands," Ma tells Axios.
  • Maybe no. Some third-party analytics providers say the ads aren't effective marketing tools. A new study by marketing analytics platform Fluent finds that 69% of Snap users report skipping ads on Snapchat "always" or "often," and that number rises to 80% among 18- to 24-year-olds, Snapchat's core audience. Fluent CMO Jordan Cohen tells Axios that millennials use Snapchat as a video messaging service, not a content service, and "that's why advertising in that format isn't that appealing to them."

Snap had revenue of $404 million in 2016, and though the company doesn't break out what comes from advertising, reports suggest that's where it makes most of its money. It ramped up its advertising efforts ahead of filing to go public and last year eMarketer projected the company would gross nearly $1 billion in advertising in 2017, nearly 2% of all social network revenue dollars in the U.S.

The big issue: Timing is a problem here. Snap ads could very well be more effective than third-party studies give them credit for, but ad buyers don't have confidence in the data. Snapchat waited too long to give them the type of measurement and reporting metrics that they are used to getting from companies like Twitter and Facebook, making them skepctical of Snapchat as a good place to buy advertising.

Go deeper

Updated 3 mins ago - Politics & Policy

Tim Scott says Trump "misspoke" when he told Proud Boys to "stand by"

Photo: Bonnie Cash/Pool/AFP via Getty Images

Sen. Tim Scott (R-S.C.) told reporters on Wednesday that he believes President Trump "misspoke" when he told the far-right "Proud Boys" group to "stand back and stand by" in response to a question about condemning white supremacy at the first presidential debate.

Catch up quick: Moderator Chris Wallace asked Trump on Tuesday, "Are you willing, tonight, to condemn white supremacists and militia groups and to say that they need to stand down?" Trump asked who specifically he should condemn, and then responded, "Proud Boys, stand back and stand by. But I'll tell you what, somebody's got to do something about antifa and the left."

45 mins ago - Podcasts

Palantir co-founder on its mission and controversies

Palantir Technologies today went public at an initial valuation of more than $21 billion, giving investors a chance to buy into one of Silicon Valley's most talked-about tech companies.

Axios Re:Cap dives into Palantir's mission and controversies with company co-founder Joe Lonsdale.

Commission on Presidential Debates wants "additional structure" for remaining debates

Photos: Jim Watson and Saul Loeb/AFP via Getty Images.

The Commission on Presidential Debates announced Wednesday that it plans to implement changes to rules for the remaining debates, after Tuesday night's head-to-head between Joe Biden and Donald Trump was practically incoherent for most of the night.

What they are saying: "Last night's debate made clear that additional structure should be added to the format of the remaining debates to ensure a more orderly discussion of the issues," the CPD said in a statement.