Dec 3, 2019

Senators' year-end push on privacy

After months of talks on bipartisan legislation, Senate Commerce Committee leaders have unveiled dueling privacy bills ahead of a hearing this week. But insiders believe the process might still yield a compromise both parties can embrace.

What they're saying: "Now there’s actually opportunity for serious negotiations between the different positions," said Jules Polonetsky, CEO of the Future of Privacy Forum, which did a comparison of the two bills. "These bills have more in common than they have dividing them."

The Republican version: Sen. Roger Wicker (R-Miss.) circulated his discussion draft, the United States Consumer Data Privacy Act, last week.

  • It would provide consumers with the ability to access, correct, delete and port data companies have about them, and it would provide limited rule-making authority to the Federal Trade Commission, according to a copy obtained by Axios.
  • But it would also preempt state privacy regulations and would not provide individual citizens with a private right of action to sue companies, two sticking points for Democrats.

The Democratic version: Sen. Maria Cantwell's (D-Wash.) Consumer Online Privacy Rights Act, also announced last week, gives the FTC greater enforcement authority and would allow consumers to enforce the law by bringing civil lawsuits.

  • "Both bills take the idea that privacy needs to be protected seriously," said Free Press senior policy counsel Gaurav Laroia.

Meanwhile, Privacy for America, a coalition of advertising industry trade groups, has a "new paradigm" for privacy out Tuesday that it sees as a third way forward on the issue.

  • Rather than focusing on obtaining consumers' consent to share data over and over, the framework calls for banning data practices that could lead to misuse, such as using data to make housing or credit eligibility decisions.
  • The idea came after a consumer survey showed that people have "notice fatigue" on privacy policies, said Stu Ingis, an adviser to the group and chairman of Venable. "The goal is to have strong protections and strong enforcement for consumers, and we think our approach does that in ways that have not previously been offered."

Yes, but: The framework would preempt California's landmark privacy law and would not allow for a private right of action.

  • "I think both of those issues become less important if you have strong protections," Ingis said.

What's next: The Wednesday hearing will likely show whether Commerce committee members are still trying to reach a compromise.

  • The House Energy & Commerce committee has been quietly working on bipartisan privacy legislation as well.

Go deeper: The future of privacy starts in California

Go deeper

Minnesota AG: Prosecution of officer in George Floyd case shouldn't be rushed

Minnesota Attorney General Keith Ellison cautioned in an interview on "Fox News Sunday" that the case against Derek Chauvin, the former Minneapolis police officer involved in the death of George Floyd, is "very early in the process" and that charges could be amended or added.

Why it matters: Chauvin was arrested last week and charged with third-degree murder and manslaughter, which implies that he did not intend to kill Floyd. Some protestors have demanded more severe charges and Floyd's family has asked Ellison to serve as a special prosecutor in the case.

Robert O'Brien: "I don't think there's systemic racism" in law enforcement

White House national security adviser Robert O'Brien said on CNN's "State of the Union" on Sunday that he doesn't believe there is "systemic racism" among law enforcement in the U.S., arguing that there are "a few bad apples" that are giving police a bad name.

Why it matters: The mass protests that have swept across the United States are not just a response to the death of George Floyd, but of the dozens of high-profile instances of unarmed black men dying at the hands of police officers over the years.

Atlanta mayor on Trump's riot response: "He speaks and he makes it worse"

Atlanta Mayor Keisha Lance Bottoms responded on CNN's "State of the Union" Sunday to President Trump's tweets and comments about the mass protests that have swept across the United States, urging him to "just stop talking."

What she's saying: "This is like Charlottesville all over again. He speaks and he makes it worse. There are times when you should just be quiet. And I wish that he would just be quiet."