1 hour ago - Business

Axios C-Suite: Don't mistake the market's fear for confidence

Illustration of Benjamin Franklin with his hand up to his face, looking out through his fingers. — Illustration: Allie Carl/Axios

Ad budgets aren't being cut — and the reason why tells us something uncomfortable about how companies are making decisions right now.

Marketing is historically the first budget to go in a crisis like war.

Not this time: The global ad market has remained relatively resilient through a cascade of economic shocks — first tariffs, now the Iran war and its energy disruption. That resilience isn't confidence. It's fear.

Three fears are doing the work that strategy should be doing:

Companies are scared to flag weak guidance because of blowback from Washington.
Analysts are scared to turn bearish after they overestimated tariff damage last year.
Wall Street isn't rewarding companies that bake uncertainty into their projections. Optimism is the winning strategy, for now.

The result: Silence that reads like strength.

Reality check: Retail trends tell a different story. A shift away from discretionary spending toward necessities is underway — and within necessities, an accelerating shift from brand names to generics.

That's the signal that cuts through the noise. When Pepsi reverses years of price increases, the consumer is telling you something the ad market hasn't priced in yet.

To ponder: The market isn't confident. It's scared to be seen as scared.

📈 If you're a CEO or on a CEO's team: Ask to join Jim's new weekly Axios C-Suite newsletter.

Add Axios on Google

Axios C-Suite: Don't mistake the market's fear for confidence

What to read next