CEO thought leadership can drive $367M in value
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios
High-quality CEO thought leadership can drive an average of $367 million in shareholder value in a single week, according to a new study by Cardinal40.
Why it matters: This study suggests words themselves can create value, independent of external news or disclosures — something communicators have long believed but haven't been able to prove.
How it works: Researchers analyzed more than 1,000 examples of CEO thought leadership from S&P 500 companies, measuring each piece against abnormal stock returns, while excluding communications tied to market-moving news.
- They tested 60-plus common writing traits, like tone and readability, and found little signal about why some outperform.
- The researchers then used AI to compare each document to a curated canon of existing, standout thought leadership.
- The analysis concluded that communications semantically closer to the canon were associated with stronger market returns.
By the numbers: The study found that the gap between top- and bottom-tier thought leadership was associated with a 0.9 percentage-point swing in stock performance the following week.
- For the largest companies, that gap can translate into billions — the report estimates as much as $25 billion for the Magnificent Seven.
Yes, but: More thought leadership does not translate into more value, an important distinction in the age of AI slop.
- Weak or low-quality communications can correlate with neutral or negative outcomes, the research finds.
The big picture: As AI makes it easier to produce content at scale, the gap between generic and high-quality thought leadership may widen.
- Companies may invest more in distinctive executive voice or storytelling efforts.
- Recently, we've seen this play out with OpenAI's acquisition of TBPN and the high paying editorial or storytelling roles at companies like Chime, Anthropic and Vanta.
- Plus, mentions of "storytelling," "narrative" and "storyteller" in corporate earnings and investor calls have increased 65% since 2020, according to AlphaSense data shared with Axios.
What they're saying: What qualifies as "good" thought leadership appears to come from the overall coherence, originality and clarity of the message, says Cardinal40 founder and CEO Ryan Jacobs.
- "We keep hearing how taste is going to actually be this incredibly important skill, because when AI is trained on everything, it loses its taste," Jacobs said. "So humans are going to need to inject their taste into it — and when they do, it can drive measurable returns."
The bottom line: While the study does not claim causation, it does point to a clear takeaway for communicators: better messaging is better business.
More on Axios:
