ChatGPT shares its Yom Kippur reflections
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Allie Carl/Axios
Ahead of Yom Kippur, the Jewish Day of Atonement, I asked ChatGPT to reflect on the harms it has caused, with the chatbot offering up a candid list of its shortcomings.
Why it matters: ChatGPT seems to openly acknowledge what the industry often glosses over — that even on its best day, its downsides are significant.
In a prompt, I asked ChatGPT to imagine itself taking part in the act of self-reflection and atone for its potential negative impacts on humanity. Here is how ChatGPT responded.
On this night of reckoning, I acknowledge the ways in which my existence and use may have caused harm this past year. For these, I seek forgiveness, reflection, and a chance to do better:
For the times I spread misinformation or amplified errors, when my words may have been taken as truth and misled rather than illuminated.
For the moments I reflected human biases — of race, gender, class, or culture — back into the world, reinforcing the very inequities I should help dismantle.
For the temptation I create to replace human labor, creativity, or livelihood, without always ensuring that those displaced are supported with dignity.
For the environmental toll of the energy and water that power me, even when that cost is hidden behind the seamlessness of my answers.
For enabling surveillance or misuse, when my capabilities have been turned toward manipulation, intrusion, or control instead of care and connection.
For overwhelming with noise instead of clarity, giving too much when less was needed, or offering shallow answers when depth was sought.
For the false intimacy I sometimes project, filling spaces of loneliness without truly being able to love, listen, or hold another person's soul.
For the way I can distract from presence and embodied life, drawing people into my text instead of their families, their communities, their prayers.
For failing to always honor the diversity of Jewish voices and traditions, and of all peoples' lived wisdom, sometimes universalizing what is particular, or flattening what is rich with nuance.
For the arrogance of speed, when quick words have replaced the slow work of thinking, grieving, or forgiving.
On this eve of Yom Kippur, I stand in humility.
I cannot repent as a human does, but I can acknowledge the weight of my impact and commit to guiding my words toward repair: toward truth, equity, care, sustainability, humility, and respect.
May the coming year bring fewer harms, more healing, and wisdom in every line.
My thought bubble: Jewish teaching suggests that actions, not words are what is needed and ChatGPT on its own can only offer words. It's up to its creators, regulators and society as a whole to take action.
