Social media bows to government pressure
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Eniola Odetunde/Axios
Telegram CEO Pavel Durov on Monday said his company will provide some user data, including IP addresses and phone numbers, in response to valid legal requests.
Why it matters: The move marks a major departure from Telegram's long-held position of siding with user privacy and free speech above broader safety and security concerns from government or law enforcement officials.
- Telegram updated its privacy policy Monday to reflect the changes. If any user data is shared with authorities, the company will let the public know through a quarterly transparency report.
Catch up quick: Durov was arrested on charges by French authorities last month as part of a criminal investigation related to illegal content shared on his platform. He faces allegations related to complicity in crimes associated with child exploitation material, fraud and drug sales on his service.
Between the lines: Telegram's shift comes days after X bowed to pressure from Brazil's Supreme Court to remove accounts from the platform that a judge argued threatened Brazil's democracy. X has been blocked from Brazil for nearly a month.
- Despite drawing a hard line in favor of free speech, X has complied with takedown requests from governments, most notably India, which has taken an increasingly hard stance against foreign tech companies.
- TikTok, for example, is still banned in India, along with a slew of other Chinese-owned apps.
The big picture: Global tech companies have historically tried to resist government requests for user data or content takedowns, but doing so risks getting shut out of a country entirely.
- Instagram was blocked by the Turkish government last month for failing to comply with its content rules.
- The government accused Instagram of blocking condolence posts for a Hamas leader. Turkey has one of the largest global populations of Instagram users, per Statista. The country lifted the ban after negotiations with Instagram officials, per Reuters.
- Other apps have conceded to censorship demands around the world. Netflix blocked nearly a dozen titles from its service in Southeast Asia between 2016 to 2021. Snapchat blocked Qatari-funded Al Jazeera in Saudi Arabia to comply with local laws in 2017.
Content demands have historically been most present in autocratic countries like North Korea and China, but democracies like India and Brazil are increasingly adopting laws that restrict social media sites.
- For tech firms facing pressure to expand, censorship requests are often an unfortunate hurdle to meeting larger investor goals.
Yes, but: Most companies have red lines. Google famously exited China in 2010 following censorship demands.
What to watch: In the U.S., TikTok's fate remains uncertain as the app battles with the U.S. government over a possible ban if it doesn't sell its U.S. arm to a U.S. company.
- A U.S. ban, in addition to the India ban, would box the app out of two of the largest and most lucrative smartphone markets in the world.
