Mar 28, 2024 - Economy

ESG on the ropes, not completely out

ESG on the ropes

ESG investing is dead. Long live ESG investing, Axios' Javier E. David writes.

Driving the news: A Pitchbook analysis of the often derided environmental, social and governance investing trend paints a mixed picture of what some critics have denounced as "woke capitalism."

  • Pitchbook notes that asset managers are retreating from ESG commitments — at least in public.
  • But it also found others are leaning into it as a method of "value creation and protection … in the challenging macroeconomic environment."

Zoom in: Pitchbook's study found that programs were being downplayed in favor of more silent support for ESG (known as "greenhushing" in certain circles).

  • Additionally, the analysis cited the "extreme" political backlash — in combination with macroeconomic factors like still-high inflation rates —as reasons for asset managers to reconsider their stance.

What they're saying: Marcos Carrington, CEO and founder of Environmental Stock Exchange (ENVX), tells Axios that "ESG is a qualitative construct created to influence behavior" that on various metrics, hasn't been "well-suited or adapted for investment in global financial markets."

Yes, but: Pitchbook insists that it's found little evidence that ESG practices sacrifice returns in the name of environmental or social goals.

Read more

avatar

This story was an excerpt from Axios Closer, a recap on the day's biggest business stories.

Read the full edition
Go deeper