Dec 30, 2020 - World

EU strikes investment deal with China despite forced labor concerns

European leaders meet via Zoom with Xi Jinping
European leaders meet via videoconference with Chinese President Xi Jinping to finalize the investment deal. Photo: Johanna Geron, Pool Photo via AP

The European Union on Wednesday finalized an agreement in principle on a long-delayed investment deal with China, appearing to defy resistance from within the EU and a request for consultations about "common concerns" from the incoming Biden administration.

Why it matters: The deal will open up both markets to investment and commit Beijing to ending certain unfair trading practices, strengthening economic ties between the EU and its second-largest trading partner.

Yes, but: The deal comes at the end of a year in which international scrutiny of the authoritarian Chinese government has grown to new heights over Beijing's handling of the coronavirus outbreak, crackdown on Hong Kong's pro-democracy movement, mass detention of Muslim minorities and other human rights abuses.

  • Members of the European Parliament, which still has to approve the deal, had mounted a last-minute bid to block the deal over China's use of forced labor, especially in the region of Xinjiang, where over 1 million Uighur Muslims and other ethnic minorities have been detained in "re-education camps."
  • Satellite imagery, interviews and government documents reported by BuzzFeed News on Tuesday revealed that China has built over 100 new factories on the same sites as the internment camps.
  • In an unusual intervention, President-elect Joe Biden's national security adviser Jake Sullivan cautioned European capitals against rushing into the deal, tweeting: "The Biden-Harris administration would welcome early consultations with our European partners on our common concerns about China's economic practices."

But despite resistance on either side of the Atlantic, the European Commission pushed forward with the talks and claimed in a breakthrough this week that China had made an "important commitment" to “make continued and sustained efforts” to pursue international forced labor standards, according to the South China Morning Post.

  • The Commission insisted to skeptical EU lawmakers that it "will remain uncompromising as to using all tools possible to eradicate any form of forced labour," and that the investment deal will play an important role in that effort.
  • Beijing, meanwhile, has denied all allegations concerning the use of forced labor, accusing those who have reported on the detention camps of meddling in domestic affairs.

Between the lines: Critics of the deal say that China acceded to European demands after seven years of negotiations in order to drive a wedge between Washington and Brussels, at a time when Biden is expected to continue some of Trump's hardline policies toward Beijing. European officials insist it will not disrupt Western cooperation on China's abuses.

Go deeper: More details on the deal from the Wall Street Journal

Go deeper