May 18, 2017

We aren't ready to engineer the climate

Our Axios Voices conversation on geoengineering.

There is no comprehensive, multilateral governance of technology to temporarily cool the planet via solar engineering. Scientists have been talking about this technology for five decades, but there has been insufficient policy discussion by governments and non-state actors. This issue is too important to be left to scientists alone.

Big questions: Some argue that ignoring technologies that might lower temperatures would be irresponsible. But the potential benefits of solar engineering claimed by others come with huge challenges and risks – known and unknown. Does research divert attention from what we know works: eliminating emissions and adapting to climate impacts? Would unequal impacts further disadvantage the poorest? Is humanity capable of intentionally engineering such a complex, carefully balanced system? On whose behalf? What global governance would be needed to monitor such a technology?

The bottom line: We face a risky future, and governance is essential to reduce those risks.

Other voices in the conversation:

Go deeper

The polarized pandemic election

A Trump supporter protests Pennsylvania's stay-at-home order, during a May 15 rally outside the Capitol in Harrisburg. Photo: Mark Makela/Getty Images

President Trump is going all-in on pushing for a rapid, robust return to normal life, creating a visual, visceral contrast with Joe Biden and other Democrats who are more reticent to rip the masks off.

The state of play: Business friends have been urging Trump from the beginning to keep the lockdowns short. He's listening more and more.

Tech's long hot summer of antitrust

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

Google, Facebook and other tech giants face a summer of regulatory grilling as long-running investigations into potential anticompetitive practices likely come to a head.

The big picture: Probes into the power of Big Tech launched by federal and state authorities are turning a year old, and observers expect action in the form of formal lawsuits and potentially damning reports — even as the companies have become a lifeline for Americans during the pandemic lockdown.

Palantir CEO hits Silicon Valley "monoculture," may leave California

Palantir is "getting close" to a decision on whether to move the company out of California, CEO Alex Karp said in an interview for "Axios on HBO."

The state of play: "We haven't picked a place yet, but it's going to be closer to the East Coast than the West Coast. ... If I had to guess, I would guess something like Colorado."