Our Axios Voices conversation on geoengineering.

These questions highlight the difficulties we will have in making a decision on geoengineering.

What do we need to know? As much as we possibly can. A choice to try geoengineering will always involve comparing the risk of human-induced climate change to the risk of human-induced climate change plus geoengineering. The more we know, the more accurate we can be about those risks.

What choices we might have: Any choice to do a geoengineering experiment — be it a small study or a deployment that would modify world climate — should involve comparing the expected gains in knowledge or climate benefits to the risks of the action.

Bottom line: Cutting carbon emissions should be tried first and foremost. (The best way to solve a problem is not to have it!) But we also need to investigate which geoengineering technologies might best compliment those efforts. Geoengineering should be thought of as one strategic element in the tool box for dealing with climate change. It should never be invoked as a stand alone technology that obviates cleaning up our energy system.

Other voices in the conversation:

Go deeper

1 min ago - Sports

13 members of St. Louis Cardinals test positive for coronavirus

Photo: Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

Seven players and six staff members from the St. Louis Cardinals have tested positive for the coronavirus over the past week, prompting the MLB to postpone the team's upcoming four-game series against the Detroit Tigers.

Why it matters: Seven consecutive Cardinals games have now been canceled after St. Louis became the second team to report a significant coronavirus outbreak, just two weeks into the season.

Updated 41 mins ago - Politics & Policy

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 3 p.m. ET: 18,149,860 — Total deaths: 690,624 — Total recoveries — 10,753,318Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 3 p.m. ET: 4,690,404 — Total deaths: 155,124 — Total recoveries: 1,468,689 — Total tests: 56,812,162Map.
  3. Politics: White House will require staff to undergo randomized coronavirus testing — Pelosi says Birx "enabled" Trump on misinformation.
  4. Business: Virtual school is another setback for retail — The pandemic hasn't hampered health care.
  5. Public health: Former FDA chief says MLB outbreaks should be warning sign for schools.
42 mins ago - Podcasts

White House adviser Peter Navarro talks TikTok

President Trump has relaxed his threat to immediately ban the popular social media app TikTok, giving Microsoft room to negotiate an acquisition from Chinese tech giant ByteDance.

Axios Re:Cap digs into the situation with Peter Navarro, the White House's top trade adviser and a noted China hawk, who suggests Microsoft should be forced to make unrelated concessions related to its China operations.