Jul 16, 2018

CRISPR editing may cause more DNA damage than expected

Illustration: Rebecca Zisser/Axios

The gene editing tool CRISPR-Cas9 may cause large deletions and rearrange the DNA it is targeting in some cases, according to a new U.K. study published in Nature Biotechnology Monday.

Why it matters: Scientists hope CRISPR can one day be used to treat cancer, HIV, haemophilia and sickle cell disease. But this and other recent studies find it can cause unintended edits, and possibly trigger cancer.

"The DNA chaos that CRISPR unleashes has been 'seriously underestimated,'” study author and geneticist Allan Bradley of U.K.'s Wellcome Sanger Center tells STAT. “This should be a wake-up call.”

What they did: The three scientists edited two types of mouse cells and human cells and sequenced long stretches of the DNA in the edited sections.

What they found: Deletions of up to several thousand DNA bases were seen, along with complex rearrangements at the target site, which means neighboring genes could be affected or cell function altered, the authors said.

  • In one experiment, they found two-thirds of the edited genes showed expected levels of small unwanted changes, but 20% of them had large unplanned deletions.
  • "As genetic damage is frequent, extensive and undetectable by the short-range PCR assays that are commonly used, comprehensive genomic analysis is warranted to identify cells with normal genomes before patient administration," the authors warned in their study.
  • Yes but: Patrick Hsu, principal investigator and Salk Helmsley Fellow at the Salk Institute for Biological Studies, tells Axios in an emailed statement, "It’s worth noting that the large deletions found in this study are still in the single digit kilobase range, so they are still mostly local events that may not necessarily affect neighboring genes."

More reactions:

  • “I do believe the findings are robust,” Gaetan Burgio of the Australian National University, who has debunked previous studies questioning the method’s safety, tells New Scientist. “This is a well-performed study and fairly significant.”
  • Very careful work is needed “to verify that the alterations to the DNA sequence are those, and only those, that had been designed to occur,” stem cell expert Robin Lovell-Badge told Reuters.“But the results give no reason to panic or to lose faith in the methods when they are carried out by those who know what they are doing.”

What's next: "This study raises important parameters that should be tracked and monitored for therapeutic applications. There are clear paths forward for each of these potential challenges, but both the challenges and solutions are still at the blackboard level. We won’t necessarily know their relative importance until we are in the clinic," says Hsu, who was not part of this study.

Go deeper

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 8 p.m. ET: 1,595,350 — Total deaths: 95,455 — Total recoveries: 353,975Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 8 p.m. ET: 461,437 — Total deaths: 16,478 — Total recoveries: 25,410Map.
  3. Public health latest: U.S. has expelled thousands of migrants under a CDC public health orderDr. Anthony Fauci said social distancing could reduce the U.S. death toll to 60,000.
  4. Business latest: The Fed will lend up to $2.3 trillion for businesses, state and city governments — After another 6.6 million jobless claims, here's how to understand the scale of American job decimation.
  5. States latest: FEMA has asked governors to decide if they want testing sites to be under state or federal control.
  6. World latest: Lockdowns have led to a decline in murders in some of the world's most violent countries — Boris Johnson is moved out of the ICU but remains in hospital with coronavirus.
  7. In Congress: Senate in stalemate over additional funding for small business relief program.
  8. 1 SNL thing: "Saturday Night Live" will return to the air this weekend with a remotely produced episode.
  9. What should I do? Hydroxychloroquine questions answeredPets, moving and personal healthAnswers about the virus from Axios expertsWhat to know about social distancingQ&A: Minimizing your coronavirus risk.
  10. Other resources: CDC on how to avoid the virus, what to do if you get it.

Subscribe to Mike Allen's Axios AM to follow our coronavirus coverage each morning from your inbox.

Federal court temporarily blocks coronavirus order against some abortions

Gov. Greg Abbott. Photo: Tom Fox-Pool/Getty Images

A federal judge ruled Thursday that clinics in Texas can immediately offer medication abortions — a pregnancy termination method administered by pill — and can also provide the procedure to patients nearing the state's time limits for abortions.

Driving the news: The decision comes after federal appeals court ruled 2-1 on Tuesday in favor of an executive order by Republican Gov. Greg Abbott that prohibits abortions during the coronavirus outbreak.

Go deeperArrowUpdated 1 hour ago - Politics & Policy

The view from the other side of the coronavirus peak

We'll soon be crowding into cafes it's 1954 in Rapallo, Italy. Photo: LIFE Picture Collection via Getty

Europeans and Americans are desperate to move beyond the worst of the crisis and return to something approximating normality, but the World Health Organization is cautioning that moving too fast will undermine the sacrifices made so far.

Where things stand: Nearly every country on Earth is still seeing their caseload increase, and a recent uptick in Singapore shows that apparent victory over the virus can be fleeting. But several countries are providing reason for optimism.

Go deeperArrow2 hours ago - World