Feb 20, 2024 - News

Making sense of Miami's chaotic political moment

Photo illustration of Miami City Hall with lines radiating from it.

Photo illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios. Photo: Joe Sohm/Visions of America/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

South Florida's 2024, so far: A former school board member arrested, Doral's city manager ousted, and three current and former Miami officials either removed from office or placed under investigation, all before Valentine's Day.

Why it matters: Political controversy is nothing new in Miami, but the chaos erupting across South Florida makes this a potentially game-changing moment in local politics.

  • What remains to be seen: whether it will bring accountability, reckoning and reform or prompt a resurgence of Miami's notorious political vendettas.

Catch up fast: On Jan. 11, former Miami-Dade school board member Lubby Navarro was arrested for allegedly spending at least $100,000 of taxpayer money on personal items, the Miami Herald reported.

What they're saying: "What we're witnessing now is the cumulative effect of unserious and ego-driven people that have populated every aspect of local government," Fernand Amandi, Democratic pollster and lecturer in the department of political science at the University of Miami, tells Axios.

  • "This is a generation of people who don't have the interest of the community in front of their own rivalries," he says. "It's something Miami-Dade has always struggled with, but it's happening now to an unprecedented and historic degree, and no area is unscathed."

Meanwhile, the city's economic and development boom has only brought out "the worst of the worst" behavior across local governments, David Marko, a business transaction lawyer and Miami native, tells Axios.

  • "Miami has always had problems, but economics have changed things," he says. The city has become "much more economically attractive [in recent years, and] real money is on the line now."

Between the lines: The challenges and removals are often coming from fellow officials, not voters. (When Herndandez was removed, dozens of community members lauded her work as Doral's city manager and urged the council to reconsider.)

  • Much of the chaos happening in the municipalities is "a war among themselves, so everything is personal," Amandi says. Coupled with the "intense political polarization" the county as a whole is grappling with, what's left is a perfect storm of infighting, he adds.

Yes, but: Former Miami Commissioner Ken Russell acknowledged that politicians have "become more brash and vindictive" and, as a result, removals have become more common. But he says the power to remove someone from office should not be weaponized.

  • "I'm very optimistic to see the checks and balances kicking in."

Bottom line: This isn't normal.

  • "What we're seeing are the signs of what a failed state starts to look like — when there's a total lack of trust and confidence in the people leading," Amandi tells Axios.
  • There's always exceptions, he adds, but when the public "throws up their hands and say, 'Because Miami,' it means that place is becoming ungovernable."

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Miami.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Miami stories

No stories could be found


Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Miami.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more