Jun 12, 2015 - Food and Drink

Saving the Brodt Building and sneak peek at Legion Brewing



Full Disclosure: Jay Levell, featured in this story, is my brother-in-law. Don’t tell my sister, but we may have had parts of this interview at the hospital this week during the birth of his new baby boy (and my nephew!).

In a town that is rallying around the hashtag #StopSterilizingCharlotte to protest the demolishing of the old to the building of the generic and shiny, it’s not typical to see a developer fight for restoration – especially when it’s no easy road. When multiple general contractors told Jay Levell of White Point Partners to bulldoze the Brodt Building he just bought and then build new, he pushed back. It’s in bad shape, it’s too costly to restore, it’s a tear down they all said.

The Backstory

Lacking any real architectural differentiators, the Brodt building is not a historical building by any means, but for the people of Charlotte it has a rich history. If you were a kid in Charlotte who played an instrument, you definitely visited the Brodt building to buy your sheet music. Since 1934, it’s where you bought your sheet music for band practice or piano lessons – a musty, paper-filled shop with a few folks repairing instruments in the basement.


For those of you new to Charlotte or otherwise not musically gifted, here’s the quick rundown:

The Brodt Timeline

1934: Cecil Brodt moves with wife Gladys from Madison, Wisconsin and opens sheet music shop downtown at current site of Hearst Tower.

1953: Shop relocates to 1906 Commonwealth Ave. in building built by Brodt.

1953-1992: For 39 years, shop sells sheet music, instruments and repairs, and serves as a community advocate for music in education and entertainment.

1992: Cecil passes, Gladys sells business and building to new ownership.

1992-2013: Over 21 years, new ownership suffers as internets, digitizing of sheet music and recession equal declining sales. Building falls into disrepair.

2013: Shop closes.

2013: White Point Partners buys the Brodt Building and the parcel beside it. The road to restoration and Legion Brewery begins.

In buying the building, Jay’s intention had always been to repurpose it.

He explains, “You look at Birmingham or Nashville, for example, that have a greater supply of older warehouse buildings that haven’t been knocked down for new construction. Those buildings that were built in the 40’s, 50’s and 60’s are the ones that have features you can’t replicate today like bow and truss roofs and unique interiors. Of course some of that is for good reason, but you can see that if done right, you can unlock these old spaces with much more character than most new construction we see these days. It is not an original formula, but one that clearly resonates with the community. With the Brodt building, we wanted to keep this as part of the fabric of the community and elevate this unique sense of place; what better way to honor the spirit of the Brodts and the community who bought music there over the years.”

They also really liked the iconic neon green sign.

Let’s be clear, due to the nature of the business, Jay and White Point must build new construction too, but this restoration project is near and dear to them because they believe Plaza Midwood has more character than anywhere in Charlotte and they wanted to keep that spirit alive.


“It’s important to honor that history, but still move forward, with a new use.”

Finding the Right Tenant

On the heels of city zoning changes that allowed production breweries to operate outside of industrial zones, White Point Partners realized that although there were multiple breweries in NoDa and South End, there was a huge void in Plaza Midwood and the Brodt space was ideal for brewing beers and serving as a gathering space.

So when Phil Buchy approached them, a contractor by trade and home-brewer for 17 years – who also happened to be instrumental in helping change the zoning laws – they knew they had found the right tenant.

brodt-old-sign charlotte

With his construction background, Phil was the man they knew would attend to the restoration process with proper care and be a good steward of the building. Not to mention, those 17 years experience as a home-brewer brought serious cred for good beers and successful business to come.

Last month, on May 4, 2015 the county approved all plans and construction on Legion Brewing began in earnest. So far, after removing a drop ceiling full of insulation, they’ve uncovered a gorgeous vaulted wood ceiling and salvaged signage, steel and wood they plan to remake into the bar, tables, chairs and decor.


Legion Brewing, The Deets  

Construction will be complete July 15th but due to various issues it seems all small businesses trying to start up in Charlotte face (another story altogether!) coupled with at least a month’s time to brew the first batches, they won’t be open until the fall.

Let’s hope the city moves faster ’cause we thirsty!

Here are the details on what’s to come …

The Space: The smaller street level front room serves as the tap room. A mezzanine opens out onto an impressive two story brew space, housed under a vaulted, wood beam ceiling. Future plans ideally include a beer garden outside on the bottom level where music events and festivals can take place.

The Beer: The tap room will have 15 taps with rotating styles. Everything from lagers to IPAs with a focus on Farmhouse Ales that use local ingredients. Brewer Phil explained, “everyone is out chasing west coast hops or ingredients from overseas, we want to celebrate the local flavors we have here in the Carolinas.”

The Food: They will serve small plates and nibbles like charcuterie and cheese and special event food and beer pairings. For example, “If we have a dessert beer, we may bring in cupcakes to complement the tasting.” (Sign me up!) But for meals, Phil doesn’t want to compete with his neighbors, “If someone is hungry, I’m going to send them to one of our neighbors – we hope to be on tap there too.”

The Decor: They are only using old world materials in build out: wood, stone, metal, porcelain. They will incorporate some music themes into the decor to elevate the history, but it won’t be all about Brodt. Old with the new!

The Art: North Carolina artist, Scott Nurkin, is set to do a mural on the Commonwealth side of the building. They also want to bring in local artists to do rotating installations on the brewery walls.

The Herb: Phil plans to plant a working herb garden out front that they can use for ingredients. Now that’s local, y’all.

Look for more updates to come as Legion Brew gets closer to opening date.


Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Charlotte.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Charlotte stories


Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Charlotte.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more